Live data from Hacker News

The Sam Altman Playbook: Fear, the Denial of Uncertainties, and Hype

garymarcus.substack.com

11–20 of 83 posts

Re: The Sam Altman Playbook: Fear, the Denial of Uncertainties, and Hype

#11
He can go ahead and create openai, the second he creates it however, it should be taken away from him and become public domain or we need to have a change in system, a true AGI should be able to automate every single industry if so then, I think everyone knows what system is the only one left to implement once humans are no longer required to work and every single factory/company produces much higher output

Re: The Sam Altman Playbook: Fear, the Denial of Uncertainties, and Hype

#12
post #9
post #6

The current AI wave is a perfect application of Conway's law: the bullshit industry has generated the perfect bullshit machines, pretending to show intelligence when they only parrot what they've heard elsewhere - badly but convincingly.

I mean, that’s too reductive. LLM’s can do all kinds of things, not just generate bullshit.

LLM can _pretend_ to do all kinds of things, and fall flat on their face as soon as they can't fake it.

Re: The Sam Altman Playbook: Fear, the Denial of Uncertainties, and Hype

#15
post #6

The current AI wave is a perfect application of Conway's law: the bullshit industry has generated the perfect bullshit machines, pretending to show intelligence when they only parrot what they've heard elsewhere - badly but convincingly.

I don't understand why people are so eager to lap up this crap.

Re: The Sam Altman Playbook: Fear, the Denial of Uncertainties, and Hype

#16
post #12
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mean, that’s too reductive. LLM’s can do all kinds of things, not just generate bullshit.

LLM can _pretend_ to do all kinds of things, and fall flat on their face as soon as they can't fake it.

I mean that's just describing a solid half of Hacker News comments on any given subject.

Re: The Sam Altman Playbook: Fear, the Denial of Uncertainties, and Hype

#17

This post is not going to age well. In fact, when GPT-5 comes out soon it's going to look positively dumb. Also GPT-4 is still leaps and bounds more capable than the competition. Anyone pushing large-language models to their limits today can easily attest to that. Claude 3 Opus comes close, but is significantly more expensive and much harder to do function calling with.

I wish I had a percentage of your childish optimism

Re: The Sam Altman Playbook: Fear, the Denial of Uncertainties, and Hype

#18

Approximately 8 billion people have accomplished less in their lives than Sam Altman... maybe criticize them instead? And so what if he's selling a vision of the future? That's a large part of entrepreneurship.

Accomplishing more != Benefiting Humanity

Re: The Sam Altman Playbook: Fear, the Denial of Uncertainties, and Hype

#19
Hard to take Gary seriously calling out "outlandish claims" with "no substance" when he does the same thing in the opposite direction.

Garbage article for clicks to pay for his lifestyle, now that he's grifted his way into being an "AI Expert" paid to pontificate with no skin in the game.

Re: The Sam Altman Playbook: Fear, the Denial of Uncertainties, and Hype

#20

Approximately 8 billion people have accomplished less in their lives than Sam Altman... maybe criticize them instead? And so what if he's selling a vision of the future? That's a large part of entrepreneurship.

Accomplishing more != Benefiting Humanity

GPT 3.5 and GPT 4 have benefited quite a lot of software engineers at a minimum. I don't see why GPT 5 would be any different.
Post reply on HN