Live data from Hacker News

All Cars Sold in the US Will Soon Have to Be Able to Automatically Avoid a Crash

theautopian.com

11–20 of 102 posts

Re: All Cars Sold in the US Will Soon Have to Be Able to Automatically Avoid a Crash

#12

I posted this same comment on the other thread, but it's worth noting here too. Headline: Most Small SUVs Are Bad at Automatic Emergency Braking, IIHS Says https://www.thedrive.com/news/most-small-suvs-are-bad-at-aut... "The SUVs that participated in the test were the Subaru Forester, Honda CR-V, Toyota RAV4, Ford Escape, Mazda CX-5, Hyundai Tucson, Jeep Compass, Mitsubishi Outlander, Chevy Equinox, and the Volkswage…

I’m not surprised about the Cx-5. Plenty to like about the vehicle, but the driver assist features are clearly an afterthought.

Re: All Cars Sold in the US Will Soon Have to Be Able to Automatically Avoid a Crash

#13

Laws to make cars smaller and drive slower will do 100x more to make crashes less deadly than fancy electronic gizmos. Not to mention all these electronics make the car much more expensive and harder to repair.

A law that prevents any FWD vehicle from going over 90 MPH, or offering significant insurance discounts, would go a long way towards reducing fatalities.

There is no reason for any casual motorist to be going 91+MPH on surface streets or highways.

Re: All Cars Sold in the US Will Soon Have to Be Able to Automatically Avoid a Crash

#14

I posted this same comment on the other thread, but it's worth noting here too. Headline: Most Small SUVs Are Bad at Automatic Emergency Braking, IIHS Says https://www.thedrive.com/news/most-small-suvs-are-bad-at-aut... "The SUVs that participated in the test were the Subaru Forester, Honda CR-V, Toyota RAV4, Ford Escape, Mazda CX-5, Hyundai Tucson, Jeep Compass, Mitsubishi Outlander, Chevy Equinox, and the Volkswage…

Oh I was quite surprised. I drive a Subaru Forester myself and thought it does quite well.

I remember original Foresters were based on sedan chassis so had pretty snappy handling for SUV but dunno about newer ones.

Re: All Cars Sold in the US Will Soon Have to Be Able to Automatically Avoid a Crash

#15

Laws to make cars smaller and drive slower will do 100x more to make crashes less deadly than fancy electronic gizmos. Not to mention all these electronics make the car much more expensive and harder to repair.

A law that prevents any FWD vehicle from going over 90 MPH, or offering significant insurance discounts, would go a long way towards reducing fatalities. There is no reason for any casual motorist to be going 91+MPH on surface streets or highways.

Isn't the car already very dangerous at 70 or so? I can't think of a lot of streets where you'd be able to get up to 90 even.

Re: All Cars Sold in the US Will Soon Have to Be Able to Automatically Avoid a Crash

#16

Laws to make cars smaller and drive slower will do 100x more to make crashes less deadly than fancy electronic gizmos. Not to mention all these electronics make the car much more expensive and harder to repair.

"Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good" applies here. Good luck convincing people to give up their big cars. Or to double their trip length by driving half the speed.

This is something that law makers can actually achieve.

Re: All Cars Sold in the US Will Soon Have to Be Able to Automatically Avoid a Crash

#17

Laws to make cars smaller and drive slower will do 100x more to make crashes less deadly than fancy electronic gizmos. Not to mention all these electronics make the car much more expensive and harder to repair.

A law that prevents any FWD vehicle from going over 90 MPH, or offering significant insurance discounts, would go a long way towards reducing fatalities. There is no reason for any casual motorist to be going 91+MPH on surface streets or highways.

there are a few reasons though, like life threatening emergencies when the road is basically empty

Re: All Cars Sold in the US Will Soon Have to Be Able to Automatically Avoid a Crash

#18

Laws to make cars smaller and drive slower will do 100x more to make crashes less deadly than fancy electronic gizmos. Not to mention all these electronics make the car much more expensive and harder to repair.

A law that prevents any FWD vehicle from going over 90 MPH, or offering significant insurance discounts, would go a long way towards reducing fatalities. There is no reason for any casual motorist to be going 91+MPH on surface streets or highways.

[deleted]

Re: All Cars Sold in the US Will Soon Have to Be Able to Automatically Avoid a Crash

#19

I posted this same comment on the other thread, but it's worth noting here too. Headline: Most Small SUVs Are Bad at Automatic Emergency Braking, IIHS Says https://www.thedrive.com/news/most-small-suvs-are-bad-at-aut... "The SUVs that participated in the test were the Subaru Forester, Honda CR-V, Toyota RAV4, Ford Escape, Mazda CX-5, Hyundai Tucson, Jeep Compass, Mitsubishi Outlander, Chevy Equinox, and the Volkswage…

Subaru has had its EyeSight collision avoidance system in production vehicles since 2010. That's a long time to refine things.

Re: All Cars Sold in the US Will Soon Have to Be Able to Automatically Avoid a Crash

#20

Laws to make cars smaller and drive slower will do 100x more to make crashes less deadly than fancy electronic gizmos. Not to mention all these electronics make the car much more expensive and harder to repair.

The reason cars are so large today is because of safety laws
Post reply on HN