Live data from Hacker News

Xbox Console Sales Are Tanking as Microsoft Brings Games to PS5

kotaku.com

11–20 of 24 posts

Re: Xbox Console Sales Are Tanking as Microsoft Brings Games to PS5

#13

The problem for Xbox is that PS5 has exclusive games, so from the consumer standpoint if you can get the Xbox games on PS5, but can’t get the important PS5 games on Xbox, then why would you buy the Xbox? Buying an Xbox means no Final Fantasy or Gran Turismo, etc.

MS has absolutely squandered the potential of the XBOX with their mismanagement of exclusive IP.

Sunset Overdrive was incredible but they let Sony buy the IP and the sequel was scrapped in favor of Spider Man.

Halo is a shell of what it once was, having abandoned split-screen co-op (after promising it post-launch).

Gears of War has run it's course.

MS have failed to innovate or effectively manage studio/publisher acquisitions so what they're left with is a PS5 that can't play a lot of PS5 games. I don't see how they rebound without a massive shift in strategy.

Re: Xbox Console Sales Are Tanking as Microsoft Brings Games to PS5

#14
post #5

Just need to allow Xbox consoles to dual boot into Windows 11 and that will solve all demand problems.

Reportedly, Phil Spencer (Microsoft Gaming CEO) wants to allow alternate app stores on Xbox consoles:

https://www.polygon.com/24108670/xbox-epic-games-store-phil-...

That would be a huge competitive advantage for Xbox, IMO.

Re: Xbox Console Sales Are Tanking as Microsoft Brings Games to PS5

#15
post #5

Just need to allow Xbox consoles to dual boot into Windows 11 and that will solve all demand problems.

That would not make any sense to Microsoft. Xbox consoles are sold at or close to manufacturing cost but it's worth it to MS because it locks consumers into their ecosystem that generates a lot of after-purchase revenue. Allowing windows on the Xbox would be equivalent to subsidizing a PC to consumers.

Re: Xbox Console Sales Are Tanking as Microsoft Brings Games to PS5

#16

The problem for Xbox is that PS5 has exclusive games, so from the consumer standpoint if you can get the Xbox games on PS5, but can’t get the important PS5 games on Xbox, then why would you buy the Xbox? Buying an Xbox means no Final Fantasy or Gran Turismo, etc.

The question is also: why would they sell consoles when they are loss leaders usually? I guess the 30% off the store, but if people are already either 1) buying it on PC cuz they release on both XBox and PC or 2) buy on PS, what's the point in it anymore?

Sony might squeeze you out of the market if they get the opportunity

Re: Xbox Console Sales Are Tanking as Microsoft Brings Games to PS5

#17
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The question is also: why would they sell consoles when they are loss leaders usually? I guess the 30% off the store, but if people are already either 1) buying it on PC cuz they release on both XBox and PC or 2) buy on PS, what's the point in it anymore?

Sony might squeeze you out of the market if they get the opportunity

I don't think they'd mind too much being squeezed out of console market if they are still selling on PS and PC and have Gamepass.

Re: Xbox Console Sales Are Tanking as Microsoft Brings Games to PS5

#18

The problem for Xbox is that PS5 has exclusive games, so from the consumer standpoint if you can get the Xbox games on PS5, but can’t get the important PS5 games on Xbox, then why would you buy the Xbox? Buying an Xbox means no Final Fantasy or Gran Turismo, etc.

You can mod skyrim on xbox at least unlike ps5

Re: Xbox Console Sales Are Tanking as Microsoft Brings Games to PS5

#19
post #5

Just need to allow Xbox consoles to dual boot into Windows 11 and that will solve all demand problems.

Reportedly, Phil Spencer (Microsoft Gaming CEO) wants to allow alternate app stores on Xbox consoles: https://www.polygon.com/24108670/xbox-epic-games-store-phil-... That would be a huge competitive advantage for Xbox, IMO.

Bring them on, squeeze out the other stores from the marketplace, and then make the terms worse over time.
Post reply on HN