I find it unfortunate that Schneier chose to underline the XZ maintainer’s mental health issues (literally—he linkified it) as the reason he’d slowed down on the project, which then led to being open to taking on the malicious co-maintainer. Schneier then follows that linkified fact up immediately with a parenthetical that Collin isn’t to blame. But then why call out that very potentially stigmatic thing at all, with…
Because the attackers successfully exploited it. And therefore it's something we need to prevent from happening again. The problem is there isn't an easy technical solution, this is is a social/medical issue that they exploited.
Backdoor in XZ Utils That Almost Happened
11–12 of 12 posts
Re: Backdoor in XZ Utils That Almost Happened
#12I find it unfortunate that Schneier chose to underline the XZ maintainer’s mental health issues (literally—he linkified it) as the reason he’d slowed down on the project, which then led to being open to taking on the malicious co-maintainer. Schneier then follows that linkified fact up immediately with a parenthetical that Collin isn’t to blame. But then why call out that very potentially stigmatic thing at all, with…
Ah, yes, the panacea for all mental health problems: brushing them under the rug and not talking about them.
His mental health wasn’t relevant to the attack from any report I’ve read. That makes it a bit odd and more than a little thoughtless to highlight it.
People slow down on projects for a ton of reasons. The guy could have been in chemo or had a kid. The result would be the same: he’d need a co-maintainer to keep the pace. The attackers would’ve capitalized on that. They’d plainly been waiting for whatever opportunity would work.