Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Ahab's Leg Dilemma

allvisibleobjects.substack.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 48 posts

Re: Ahab's Leg Dilemma

#11

Post by Jun8 »

Going down the rabbit hole on minutiae like this is a joy to research and read.

Had Melville known about the very strong clicks that sperm whales can produce he probably could have woken in it as an interesting motif, e.g. MB "talking" to Ahab or other sailors or killing them with his clicks: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicBookClub/comments/phhs5v/mob...

After I read this, a tangential thought occurred to me: which hand and which finger does the One Ring go? Luckily that's specified more in the LoTR books: https://www.reddit.com/r/tolkienfans/comments/2ia4a0/which_f..., https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/13810/why-was-the-....

Re: Ahab's Leg Dilemma

#12

Post by Zigurd »

"Captain Ahab, from Herman Melville's novel "Moby-Dick," is missing his left leg, which was bitten off by the white whale, Moby Dick, at the knee."

According to ChatGPT.

Re: Ahab's Leg Dilemma

#13

Post by Zigurd »

Zigurd wrote: post #12

"Captain Ahab, from Herman Melville's novel "Moby-Dick," is missing his left leg, which was bitten off by the white whale, Moby Dick, at the knee. " According to ChatGPT.

The follow-up, when I asked "why do you think so":

My statement that Captain Ahab is missing his left leg is based on common interpretations and summaries of Herman Melville's "Moby-Dick." However, upon reflection, I realize that specific textual evidence is crucial for such details. In the novel, Melville describes how Ahab's leg was taken by the whale, and Ahab uses a whalebone prosthesis as a replacement. The narrative provides vivid descriptions of Ahab's movements and the implications of his injury, which significantly affects his character and actions throughout the story.

To accurately determine which leg Ahab is missing, one would need to consult the text of "Moby-Dick" directly. My previous response was based on a general understanding of the novel and its character, but I acknowledge the importance of textual accuracy, especially with classic literature. If the text specifically states which leg was lost or implies it through Ahab's actions or descriptions, that would be the definitive source.

Re: Ahab's Leg Dilemma

#14

Post by n4r9 »

lupire wrote: post #6
n4r9 wrote: post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don't forget that Euler invented graph theory to solve an inconsequential riddle (the Bridges of Konigsberg).

Not really. Euler was inspired by the trivial riddle to create graph theory. Graph theory answered many, many interesting questions.

I'm afraid I'm not sure where you're differing from what I said! He invented graph theory to solve the riddle. It was later used to solve other problems as well. It's not clear to me that Euler knew of the myriad possible applications, but would be happy to be shown wrong.

Re: Ahab's Leg Dilemma

#16

Post by transitionnel »

Jun8 wrote: post #11

Going down the rabbit hole on minutiae like this is a joy to research and read. Had Melville known about the very strong clicks that sperm whales can produce he probably could have woken in it as an interesting motif, e.g. MB "talking" to Ahab or other sailors or killing them with his clicks: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicBookClub/comments/phhs5v/mob... After I read this, a tangential thought occurred to me: which…

Ringwise, I think marriages just got a lot more fun!

Re: Ahab's Leg Dilemma

#17

Post by transitionnel »

transitionnel wrote: post #16
Jun8 wrote: post #11

Going down the rabbit hole on minutiae like this is a joy to research and read. Had Melville known about the very strong clicks that sperm whales can produce he probably could have woken in it as an interesting motif, e.g. MB "talking" to Ahab or other sailors or killing them with his clicks: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicBookClub/comments/phhs5v/mob... After I read this, a tangential thought occurred to me: which…

Ringwise, I think marriages just got a lot more fun!

"SegaIrraM" in Parseltongue

Re: Ahab's Leg Dilemma

#18

Post by keiferski »

If you haven’t read Moby Dick, you really should. It’s impressive in a way that modern literature just misses entirely. It is simply an incredible piece of work.

But – try to read it on a long trip, or during an airplane ride. It is not the kind of work you should rush through. Personally I read it on a series of 10+ hour airplane rides, which was the perfect environment IMO, perhaps only second to a weeks-long sailing trip.

Re: Ahab's Leg Dilemma

#19

Post by cassepipe »

xutopia wrote: post #3

I'm always impressed how someone goes on to try to find an answer for something that ultimately isn't all that important in the grand scheme of things. Nevertheless I find myself fascinating by this author's journey to figure this detail out.

Congrats, you unlocked the level 2 video : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ex74x_gqTU0
Post reply on HN