Gitspective - Facebook style timeline for your GitHub feed • Hacker News Board

Re: Gitspective - Facebook style timeline for your GitHub feed

#11

Post by trustfundbaby » Wed, May 09, 2012, 8:20 PM UTC

zmoazeni wrote: post #8

empire29 wrote: post #6

Fun project, but am I the only one that finds the zig-zag flow of the "Fb-timeline" difficult to follow -- or atleast more difficult than a linear feed? What are the advantages of this style of timeline - other than less scrolling?

I do think there may be some honest criticisms for it. But regarding gitspective, my design is bad. Very bad. So bad, I considered making everything shades of hot pink so it might motivate a designer (who would normally pass) to help me out. I would expect with a better design the back-and-forth would flow would look a lot easier on the eyes.

Why are you married to the back-and-forth thing anyway?

Is it just because facebook does it, or do you have some other strong reason for using it.

Re: Gitspective - Facebook style timeline for your GitHub feed

#12

Post by zmoazeni » Wed, May 09, 2012, 8:27 PM UTC

trustfundbaby wrote: post #11

zmoazeni wrote: post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I do think there may be some honest criticisms for it. But regarding gitspective, my design is bad. Very bad. So bad, I considered making everything shades of hot pink so it might motivate a designer (who would normally pass) to help me out. I would expect with a better design the back-and-forth would flow would look a lot easier on the eyes.

Why are you married to the back-and-forth thing anyway? Is it just because facebook does it, or do you have some other strong reason for using it.

I wouldn't say I'm married to it. I actually like the Facebook timeline, and it is what inspired this project. I wondered what my github feed would look like in a timeline/filterable form. So I built it.

The main goal is to be able to take anyone's public github profile and assess what they have done in the open source world. For example, a job candidate who gives sends along their profile. Right now their public github profile page doesn't do a great job distilling that information.

Re: Gitspective - Facebook style timeline for your GitHub feed

#13

Post by ryankirkman » Thu, May 10, 2012, 6:41 AM UTC

ntkachov wrote: post #7

empire29 wrote: post #6

Fun project, but am I the only one that finds the zig-zag flow of the "Fb-timeline" difficult to follow -- or atleast more difficult than a linear feed? What are the advantages of this style of timeline - other than less scrolling?

The zig-zag flow is one of the most obnoxious things i've ever seen in a website. It is one of the worst ways of displaying information ever. Lets take this to the extream. Lets say you had a serverlog with 1 million entries and you had to parse it by hand for what ever reason. would you rather see [Jun 10, 12:32] /index.html 200 54ms nick [Jun 10, 12:32] /index.html 200 54ms nick [Jun 10, 12:32] /index.html 200 54ms…

The Facebook timeline acknowledges that many modern displays have more horizontal real estate than vertical real estate. The design reflects this. It uses much larger visual elements (boxes) than a line of text which means it maximizes its use of both vertical real estate and horizontal real estate.

The other thing you're not considering is that Facebook displays more than just text. If you're displaying images inline as well as text, it's going to be more compact if you interpolate each post in a zig-zag fashion rather than making posts vertically serial.

The example you provided doesn't really illustrate why timeline is bad for a website because it's an example provided in a completely different context.

tl;dr Website design is not command line interface design.