11–20 of 162 posts
Now I know why I dislike Svelte so much, I don't believe in its principles. Which is perfectly fine, a framework can't please everyone. HTML is not the mother language - It's actually pretty terrible for describing dynamic user interfaces. This is why JS solutions are so appealing. If HTML is so magical why do they need a fancy template language? Magical, not magic - I really don't want it to feel magical either. I l…
I like using Rich Harris's tools because he cares about actually getting stuff done and he's allergic to bullshit
one of the upvoted comments says 'Rich for president'
Except that svelte advertises itself constantly as being faster and with smaller bundle sizes. Which is a good thing. I don't buy that it priortizes 'good vibes' at the cost of those other things. If it's saying it prioritizes 'good vibes' and everything else, then that's pretty meaningless - they might as well say they're good at everything.
Would also help to actually define what 'good vibes' are because I think every tool tries to make DX as nice as possible.
I honestly dislike fluff like this because it conveys nothing and gives fodder for people to ignore practical evidence in favor of biased advertising i.e. someone's going to make a bullet point list about things they dislike, and someone will just point to this and say "nuh uh, you're wrong, they care about being user-friendly, it says so right here".
Since we're talking about front-end frameworks, I still maintain that vue has some of the best documentation. I fell in love with vue 2 because the documentation did a great balancing act between being brief, simple, and somehow dense at the same time. In particular, I remember a page about it's comparisons to other frameworks that in a few paragraphs, gave a history lesson, simplified differences to barebones, explained the practical implications all in a way that put vue in a good light. It was much better than the angular and react docs at the time.
> We want Svelte to feel magical — we want you to feel like a wizard when you're writing Svelte code... So when we design things we need to think about the people who haven't read the docs in a while, if at all, and don't care about things like that. This means that things need to be intuitive, that we shouldn't need to worry about manual optimisations like memoisation, that we should have as few APIs as possible, an…
Now I know why I dislike Svelte so much, I don't believe in its principles. Which is perfectly fine, a framework can't please everyone. HTML is not the mother language - It's actually pretty terrible for describing dynamic user interfaces. This is why JS solutions are so appealing. If HTML is so magical why do they need a fancy template language? Magical, not magic - I really don't want it to feel magical either. I l…
Compared to... what? XML? QML? XIB?
There's literally nothing better than HTML for UI. Anything else is either buried in a mountain of proprietary nonsense, is platform specific, or is far inferior technically.
Now I know why I dislike Svelte so much, I don't believe in its principles. Which is perfectly fine, a framework can't please everyone. HTML is not the mother language - It's actually pretty terrible for describing dynamic user interfaces. This is why JS solutions are so appealing. If HTML is so magical why do they need a fancy template language? Magical, not magic - I really don't want it to feel magical either. I l…
I feel very different than you, but I am sincerely glad you have clarity and that you better understand what YOU are looking for :) having said that, we'll likely end up happily working on different things in different pastures
> We want Svelte to feel magical — we want you to feel like a wizard when you're writing Svelte code... So when we design things we need to think about the people who haven't read the docs in a while, if at all, and don't care about things like that. This means that things need to be intuitive, that we shouldn't need to worry about manual optimisations like memoisation, that we should have as few APIs as possible, an…
What makes Vue "insanely" more productive than React ?
Now I know why I dislike Svelte so much, I don't believe in its principles. Which is perfectly fine, a framework can't please everyone. HTML is not the mother language - It's actually pretty terrible for describing dynamic user interfaces. This is why JS solutions are so appealing. If HTML is so magical why do they need a fancy template language? Magical, not magic - I really don't want it to feel magical either. I l…
That's because HTML is the native language for describing UI in the browser.
No matter what you use to specify UI, you have to understand how it translates to HTML to use it in the browser (and how HTML translates back, for debugging). The further your UI specification language deviates from HTML the harder that it.
Of course, there are plenty of people using various frameworks that don't really understand HTML or how the code they write translates to it. But they end up with crappy web sites and bugs they don't know how to fix and various other compromises and frustrations.
Now I know why I dislike Svelte so much, I don't believe in its principles. Which is perfectly fine, a framework can't please everyone. HTML is not the mother language - It's actually pretty terrible for describing dynamic user interfaces. This is why JS solutions are so appealing. If HTML is so magical why do they need a fancy template language? Magical, not magic - I really don't want it to feel magical either. I l…