Live data from Hacker News

Remote work doesn't seem to affect productivity, Fed study finds

bloomberg.com

11–20 of 597 posts

Re: Remote work doesn't seem to affect productivity, Fed study finds

#11

layoffs are mostly done. so the media is starting to lay the foundation for offshoring of jobs to remote, cheaper locations.

Offshoring has been a thing for a few decades now. So has the technology that facilitates remote work. So I don't think this is some new push for offshoring.

Re: Remote work doesn't seem to affect productivity, Fed study finds

#13
> The researchers examined productivity trends in 43 industries — including chemical manufacturing, retail trade, and accommodation and food services — and assigned a “teleworkability” score based on the occupational mix of each industry and the share of jobs that can be done remotely.

This does not seem like a very strong study.

Re: Remote work doesn't seem to affect productivity, Fed study finds

#14

Most employees can screw around websurfing or shopping just as well at work as at home. They mostly do it because they are bored. Give them interesting, meaningful work and they will be productive.

Water cooler chat used to be the big thing when I worked in an office.

Re: Remote work doesn't seem to affect productivity, Fed study finds

#15

Most employees can screw around websurfing or shopping just as well at work as at home. They mostly do it because they are bored. Give them interesting, meaningful work and they will be productive.

Work avoidance typically stems from fear of failure, not boredom. If workers are screwing around when there is work that needs to be done, that is indicative of an environment that doesn't provide the proper failsafes.

That said, a lot of jobs simply don't have a constant stream of work that needs to be done, with the work available being dependent on when the customer chooses to engage. It is likely that for a lot of jobs downtime is just the name of the game and without changing customer habits there isn't much you can do.

Re: Remote work doesn't seem to affect productivity, Fed study finds

#16
post #13

> The researchers examined productivity trends in 43 industries — including chemical manufacturing, retail trade, and accommodation and food services — and assigned a “teleworkability” score based on the occupational mix of each industry and the share of jobs that can be done remotely. This does not seem like a very strong study.

Why?

Re: Remote work doesn't seem to affect productivity, Fed study finds

#17
post #3

Most employees can screw around websurfing or shopping just as well at work as at home. They mostly do it because they are bored. Give them interesting, meaningful work and they will be productive.

Some do it to get a break. Doing 40 hours of straight “creative” work is impossible.

Seriously. As an engineer and engineering leader, I cannot maintain focus to code, sit in meetings, and a variety of other tasks for more than 2-3 hours without a break. It is good to get up, move around, catch up on the news, etc. Taking appropriate breaks and conducting self care gives my mind an opportunity to decompress, allowing me to come back to work more focused and productive. Very long sessions (5+ hours) without a break tend to run into a wall - I may still be doing work, but the quality drops precipitously. Sometimes, I can raise my productivity by distracting myself with home chores (e.g. laundry). Sometimes, I find a quick dip into the news or a catchup on our friend group's discord server productive. This may not be the same for all of us, but studies have repeatedly shown breaks improve productivity for most individuals. Being outside the office, I find it much more convenient to take a productive break without having other coworkers distracting me. Looking over studies and suggestions, it seems interesting to me that tasks like meditation, power naps, small chores, snacks, listening to music, and interacting with pets are much more easily conducted in the comfort of our homes.

https://learningcenter.unc.edu/tips-and-tools/taking-breaks/ https://hbr.org/2023/05/how-to-take-better-breaks-at-work-ac...

Re: Remote work doesn't seem to affect productivity, Fed study finds

#18

Most employees can screw around websurfing or shopping just as well at work as at home. They mostly do it because they are bored. Give them interesting, meaningful work and they will be productive.

Water cooler chat used to be the big thing when I worked in an office.

Bah, thing of the past! Now it's mostly organic breakthrough moments of creativity. At a few places it's serendipitious collaboration, of course.

Re: Remote work doesn't seem to affect productivity, Fed study finds

#19
post #3

Most employees can screw around websurfing or shopping just as well at work as at home. They mostly do it because they are bored. Give them interesting, meaningful work and they will be productive.

Some do it to get a break. Doing 40 hours of straight “creative” work is impossible.

Not only creative work, but manual work too. It's been over 100 years that Frederick Taylor showed regular breaks reduces fatigue and increases productivity. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_management

Re: Remote work doesn't seem to affect productivity, Fed study finds

#20
post #11

layoffs are mostly done. so the media is starting to lay the foundation for offshoring of jobs to remote, cheaper locations.

Offshoring has been a thing for a few decades now. So has the technology that facilitates remote work. So I don't think this is some new push for offshoring.

In fairness, there does seem to be a lot of concern amongst the management class around keeping their jobs if they don't get back into the office.

Historically, offshoring's biggest struggle has been finding a cultural alignment with those still working in the onshore office. But when everyone is remote there is no such barrier. That is, in the grand scheme of things, something new.

Post reply on HN