Live data from Hacker News

Ring of galaxies challenges thinking on cosmos

bbc.com

11–13 of 13 posts

Re: Ring of galaxies challenges thinking on cosmos

#11
post #5

The bbc has a better article in their science section at https://www.bbc.co.uk/future/article/20230302-the-giant-arcs... dated March 2023. Today’s article is triggered by a presentation of results but contains less information.

That's now dated January 12, 2024 and was edited to include this latest news and a link to the new article.

Re: Ring of galaxies challenges thinking on cosmos

#12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All the illustrations we see about galaxies are post-processed interpretations, they are not exactly photos per se. In this case, I think astronomers may be using the data sent by the Voyagers[1] as a ground truth for trying to interpolate the scanned one from distant galaxies. It is not my field, but perhaps another probe should have been launched on a different axis as you indirectly suggest, although it should hav…

Other galaxies are too far away for us to have any way to view them from a significantly different angle -- the solar system is tiny compared to the size of galaxies and the distance between them. How does the voyager article relate to this study? It looks like voyager just got far enough away from the sun to detect something in our galaxy that was hard to see from earth due to being drowned out by the sun, and the r…

Apologies, I didn't thought in the scale.

Certainly it is zero related to this study. I read the article that I linked thinking the Voyagers reached a distance far enough to use it as a stereoscopy through two sources, Earth and Voyager, with the Voyager's collected data. And therefore I thought that's what astronomers in general was using as reference to analyze galaxies (in the last decade).

After read again such article I keep thinking about how did I reached this process. Apologies again to everyone.

PS: I didn't noticed it was behind a paywall, maybe by this Archive capture,

http://web.archive.org/web/20151203203335/https://www.newsci...

Re: Ring of galaxies challenges thinking on cosmos

#13
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Other galaxies are too far away for us to have any way to view them from a significantly different angle -- the solar system is tiny compared to the size of galaxies and the distance between them. How does the voyager article relate to this study? It looks like voyager just got far enough away from the sun to detect something in our galaxy that was hard to see from earth due to being drowned out by the sun, and the r…

Apologies, I didn't thought in the scale. Certainly it is zero related to this study. I read the article that I linked thinking the Voyagers reached a distance far enough to use it as a stereoscopy through two sources, Earth and Voyager, with the Voyager's collected data. And therefore I thought that's what astronomers in general was using as reference to analyze galaxies (in the last decade). After read again such a…

No need to apologize. You might have been thinking of parallax due to earth location changing as it orbits the sun, which causes very small shifts in the apparent angular positions of stars. Closer stars shift more, which allows it to be used as a distance measurement to stars, but the effect is too small to measure for far away galaxies.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallax_in_astronomy

Post reply on HN