Live data from Hacker News

TACF is no longer supporting development of D58 American chestnut trees

tacf.org

11–20 of 61 posts

Re: TACF is no longer supporting development of D58 American chestnut trees

#11
post #8
post #2

The current seeds given to the public the ACF were counting on have very poor survival/growth metrics and they're giving up on that line; big shame as those are the seeds they offered to donors (and thus a way of getting involved as as outsider).

I bought some of those seeds and I just thought I had a black thumb. I planted my surviving seedlings this fall, a month before frost, and I hope they will survive winter..

I live in blight region (NJ). We have American seedlings growing here for a few years now, but I don't have faith that inside the range they'll reach maturity.

Our mature American Chestnut tree is well established enough that it dies back some every few decades and recovers. This year I got 50 or so chestnuts out of it. I ate a few, they are great and never seem to get the weevil that the Chinese trees we have do (basically if I don't process the Chinese ones immediately after harvesting in a hot water bath, they will have a grub bore out of them in a week or so).

Been trying to find people outside blight region (somewhere like Michigan/Wisconsin) to plant the American ones so they have a shot. This tree is not a result of any of the ACF's crossbreeding, it's just a survivor that's over 100 years old.

Re: TACF is no longer supporting development of D58 American chestnut trees

#16

American chestnut was the redwood of the east. Its damn shame it is not thriving

Tried to respond to this before maybe the site will let me now. There's a redwood that was thought to be extinct that thrives in east coast conditions of the US. The dawn redwood is a fast grower, and while being the smallest of the redwood species is still quite a large tree. It was discovered in a valley in China I guess back in the 40's, previously only known to the fossil record.

We have one here planted in the 1970's that towers over my house and had one next to my childhood home. It's amazing they do as well as they do, but the concern now is genetic bottleneck since most of the seeds planted worldwide were from a few trees, so the successive generations I guess don't do as well as the ones in that valley do.

Re: TACF is no longer supporting development of D58 American chestnut trees

#17
Pity. I had hopes.

When i was little, we had a neighbor who had a few American Chestnut trees of bearing age. He had an annual business collecting and selling the nuts; he wouldn't let anybody know where the trees were.

still fondly recall the flavor of the real chestnuts.

Re: TACF is no longer supporting development of D58 American chestnut trees

#19
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I bought some of those seeds and I just thought I had a black thumb. I planted my surviving seedlings this fall, a month before frost, and I hope they will survive winter..

I live in blight region (NJ). We have American seedlings growing here for a few years now, but I don't have faith that inside the range they'll reach maturity. Our mature American Chestnut tree is well established enough that it dies back some every few decades and recovers. This year I got 50 or so chestnuts out of it. I ate a few, they are great and never seem to get the weevil that the Chinese trees we have do (ba…

I'm around there and am interested in adding new trees to my yard. If you're serious, drop me an email.

Re: TACF is no longer supporting development of D58 American chestnut trees

#20
Click baity - they are ceasing distribution of blight resistant seeds that died more frequently than expected. It’s not viable in wild so no go.

This headline would have you thinking they’re holding back progress or something. But it’s clear they are the opposite, cutting their losses and investing elsewhere.

Post reply on HN