Live data from Hacker News

Canadian government reaches deal with Google on Online News Act

cbc.ca

11–20 of 213 posts

Re: Canadian government reaches deal with Google on Online News Act

#11
post #5

I'm no fan of Google, but if it was me making the decision I would have told them to pack sand. Google is providing them with a service, not the other way around.

I'm not taking sides but the issue is Canadian content. Because both countries share the same language, but there is a huge mismatch in economic might, Canadian content finds it hard to compete with American content. Mexico doesn't have the same problem largely because of language.

Re: Canadian government reaches deal with Google on Online News Act

#12
post #8
post #5

I'm no fan of Google, but if it was me making the decision I would have told them to pack sand. Google is providing them with a service, not the other way around.

Agree completely. What's in it for Google? Will they really make that much more money providing news, versus just cutting Canada off?

They should not have settled. Probably ran the numbers and for ad+search revenue and noticed it was worth it for $100m. If/Maybe you are making 300m then it's okay to give up that 100 to keep 200.

And who gets to distribute the revenue?

Re: Canadian government reaches deal with Google on Online News Act

#13
post #5

I'm no fan of Google, but if it was me making the decision I would have told them to pack sand. Google is providing them with a service, not the other way around.

What is the service? Indexing and aggregating news? This is commodity now.

Do you find this more valuable than the act of actually researching, writing, editing, and publishing the articles themselves?

Re: Canadian government reaches deal with Google on Online News Act

#14
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Countries are now extorting American tech companies, that’s what’s really going on here.

Yeah it’s a shakedown. I don’t see them getting any money out of Facebook though. I actually think Facebook is a better experience for users without news.

Facebook, all Meta properties no longer allow sharing anything considered news in Canada. If you put in a link to a news site it will be blocked. At one point they were event blocking news satire. People sharing news now will drop in an image instead of a link. Much less useful.

Re: Canadian government reaches deal with Google on Online News Act

#15
post #13
post #5

I'm no fan of Google, but if it was me making the decision I would have told them to pack sand. Google is providing them with a service, not the other way around.

What is the service? Indexing and aggregating news? This is commodity now. Do you find this more valuable than the act of actually researching, writing, editing, and publishing the articles themselves?

It's advertising. Google drives traffic to the articles.

If Google stops linking to news articles, media companies would be the bigger losers than Google would be. Admittedly Google isn't Facebook -- it's value to users comes from indexing everything. This is probably why they accepted this deal.

As a Canadian, I wish that they'd just gone ahead and blocked Canadian news.

Re: Canadian government reaches deal with Google on Online News Act

#16
"The new regulations will allow Google to negotiate with a single group that would represent all media, allowing the company to limit its arbitration risk." - I'm sure this will be a large and diverse group representing the growing diversity of media in Canada, either that or it will be Rogers, Bell and Postmedia doing what they usually do, which is really nothing of value.

Re: Canadian government reaches deal with Google on Online News Act

#17
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Countries are now extorting American tech companies, that’s what’s really going on here.

Yeah it’s a shakedown. I don’t see them getting any money out of Facebook though. I actually think Facebook is a better experience for users without news.

I'm not sure if this is what you meant but just in case, from the article: "Meta [...] ended its talks with the government last summer and stopped distributing Canadian news on Facebook and Instagram".

Re: Canadian government reaches deal with Google on Online News Act

#18
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah it’s a shakedown. I don’t see them getting any money out of Facebook though. I actually think Facebook is a better experience for users without news.

Facebook, all Meta properties no longer allow sharing anything considered news in Canada. If you put in a link to a news site it will be blocked. At one point they were event blocking news satire. People sharing news now will drop in an image instead of a link. Much less useful.

I think news sharing on Facebook mainly leads to outrage spirals and toxic engagement. That’s why I say the platform is better off without it. I’m disappointed that people have been able to circumvent the block with screenshots though.

Re: Canadian government reaches deal with Google on Online News Act

#19
I always thought the intention was to get the same deal as Australia: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-australia-56163550. It's not a surprise that Canada's media industry wanted the same deal and the government was willing to go to bat for it.

The BBC article from 2021 linked above even says "The law is seen as a test case for similar regulation around the world."

Post reply on HN