Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Meta Designed Products to Capitalize on Teen Vulnerabilities, States Allege

wsj.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 170 posts

Re: Meta Designed Products to Capitalize on Teen Vulnerabilities, States Allege

#11

Post by maximinus_thrax »

avalys wrote: post #4

Do grocery stores “capitalize on vulnerability” when they place name-brand products at eye level? Do carmakers “capitalize on vulnerability” when they advertise pickup trucks as big tough vehicles for tough, outdoorsy men? Do providers of health insurance for pets “capitalize on vulnerability” when they say you need to buy their product if you love your pet? At some point people need to be responsible for their own d…

> At some point people need to be responsible for their own decisions.

We already do that. When they turn 18, we expect people to be responsible for their own decisions.

Re: Meta Designed Products to Capitalize on Teen Vulnerabilities, States Allege

#12

Post by BizarreByte »

NickC25 wrote: post #3

Should come as no surprise, honestly. Above all else since turning public, Meta is in the business of making money. It's not illegal to target user's vulnerabilities in order to get the user to spend more time or money on their platform. It's unethical as hell, but it's business 101 - the shareholders would revolt if Zuck came out and said "here's this opportunity to make you all a ton of money, but we're placing our…

> It's not illegal to target user's vulnerabilities in order to get the user to spend more time or money on their platform.

Perhaps it should be illegal to target children in such ways? I'm tired of this argument that companies should be able to do whatever they wish in the name of profit, they need to be reigned with strong regulations.

Re: Meta Designed Products to Capitalize on Teen Vulnerabilities, States Allege

#13

Post by switchbak »

avalys wrote: post #4

Do grocery stores “capitalize on vulnerability” when they place name-brand products at eye level? Do carmakers “capitalize on vulnerability” when they advertise pickup trucks as big tough vehicles for tough, outdoorsy men? Do providers of health insurance for pets “capitalize on vulnerability” when they say you need to buy their product if you love your pet? At some point people need to be responsible for their own d…

Do grocery stores “capitalize on vulnerability” when they ... place junk food at the checkout line to capitalize on your impulsiveness when you're least able to defend against it?

Yes.

You can be expected to make responsible decisions as an adult. That doesn't mean that there aren't bad actors trying to take advantage of you, and that this behaviour isn't borderline unethical.

Re: Meta Designed Products to Capitalize on Teen Vulnerabilities, States Allege

#14

Post by zooq_ai »

I for one hope this case reach the supreme court and it's struck down on egregious Government overreach. This case has no proof about net harm to teenagers by social media.

This case is basically projecting everyone's misplaced hate of social media without doing a proper controlled experiment of it's benefits/harm to the society.

You can't do controlled experiments on humans and hence the states have no case except overreach. If they really want to cater to their constituents then pass specific laws.

Re: Meta Designed Products to Capitalize on Teen Vulnerabilities, States Allege

#15

Post by alakin »

quacked wrote: post #7
avalys wrote: post #4

Do grocery stores “capitalize on vulnerability” when they place name-brand products at eye level? Do carmakers “capitalize on vulnerability” when they advertise pickup trucks as big tough vehicles for tough, outdoorsy men? Do providers of health insurance for pets “capitalize on vulnerability” when they say you need to buy their product if you love your pet? At some point people need to be responsible for their own d…

Yes, yes, and yes. However, the three situations you named are targeting adults. Children and teenagers are worth insulating from the full might of advertisers, propagandists, and always-on virtual social circles.

Are children and young adults banned from selecting products based on marketing inside stores?

Re: Meta Designed Products to Capitalize on Teen Vulnerabilities, States Allege

#16

Post by asylteltine »

zooq_ai wrote: post #14

I for one hope this case reach the supreme court and it's struck down on egregious Government overreach. This case has no proof about net harm to teenagers by social media. This case is basically projecting everyone's misplaced hate of social media without doing a proper controlled experiment of it's benefits/harm to the society. You can't do controlled experiments on humans and hence the states have no case except o…

Teenagers started having extreme and rampant mental health issues as soon as social media became pervasive. I’m sure it’s just a coincidence though.

Re: Meta Designed Products to Capitalize on Teen Vulnerabilities, States Allege

#18

Post by stillwithit »

avalys wrote: post #4

Do grocery stores “capitalize on vulnerability” when they place name-brand products at eye level? Do carmakers “capitalize on vulnerability” when they advertise pickup trucks as big tough vehicles for tough, outdoorsy men? Do providers of health insurance for pets “capitalize on vulnerability” when they say you need to buy their product if you love your pet? At some point people need to be responsible for their own d…

[flagged]

Re: Meta Designed Products to Capitalize on Teen Vulnerabilities, States Allege

#19

Post by Teever »

alakin wrote: post #15
quacked wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, yes, and yes. However, the three situations you named are targeting adults. Children and teenagers are worth insulating from the full might of advertisers, propagandists, and always-on virtual social circles.

Are children and young adults banned from selecting products based on marketing inside stores?

Canada has forbidden the sale of cigarettes in grocery stores, and they've banned the display of any advertising for them in the stores that are still allowed to sell them.
Post reply on HN