Live data from Hacker News

Bring Back Webrings

arne.me

11–20 of 91 posts

Re: Bring Back Webrings

#11
post #3
post #2

This webring isn't so much a ring as a wire, as one of the websites doesn't have the footer. This was always the problem with webrings in the first place - one broken link in the chain ruins it for everyone. Just like token ring based LANs

Just rebrand them as WebDAGs.

Directed acyclic graphs?

Re: Bring Back Webrings

#12
post #2

This webring isn't so much a ring as a wire, as one of the websites doesn't have the footer. This was always the problem with webrings in the first place - one broken link in the chain ruins it for everyone. Just like token ring based LANs

Yes, good webrings always needed an active ringmaster.

I do think webrings are badly needed again, though, to serve the same purpose they were developed for in the first place: discoverability.

It's become very difficult to find the good (according to my tastes) websites these days.

Re: Bring Back Webrings

#13
post #5
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just rebrand them as WebDAGs.

I kind of like this idea, but then instead of just left and right arrows I want to be able to travel in a multi-dimensional space :)

Links between websites in a sort of hyper-dimensional space! A...hyper-link?

Re: Bring Back Webrings

#15
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I kind of like this idea, but then instead of just left and right arrows I want to be able to travel in a multi-dimensional space :)

This could be pretty basic browser extension. A little banner at the top or bottom: “websites like this one”

Or website curators all agree on a /webring.txt file (similar to a robots.txt) where they list websites they think are similar?

Re: Bring Back Webrings

#17
post #2

This webring isn't so much a ring as a wire, as one of the websites doesn't have the footer. This was always the problem with webrings in the first place - one broken link in the chain ruins it for everyone. Just like token ring based LANs

Web rung?

Re: Bring Back Webrings

#19
I'm fairly certain that link-aggregation sites, like Hacker News, Reddit, Digg, Slashdot, and Lemmy have taken the place of Webrings.

The sad truth about webpages is that people don't want to maintain them. People will put in their weekend project, and then the webpage sits there for the rest of eternity whether or not its relevant, and then what? When do you update the webring so that they add and/or remove pages?

Here's another idea: you put up links regularly to a webpage that dynamically sorts them by popularity, relevance, and date. Oh wait, that's Reddit.

Re: Bring Back Webrings

#20
My partner works in corporate communications and so we frequently lament the enshitification, specifically the way social media as a concept destroyed so many things and now is experiencing its own gotterdammerung. It feels like at the moment we are in a middle place, waiting for the next trend. Perhaps it will be a return to the super personalization of the 1990s, where everyone was making content of their own and expressing themselves online with their own flavors before the "platformization" came along. Post-Covid there appears to be a resurgence in community, in "authenticity" so logically it follows that our online engagement might follow a similar pattern.
Post reply on HN