Live data from Hacker News

Germany approves global minimum corporate tax

reuters.com

11–20 of 54 posts

Re: Germany approves global minimum corporate tax

#11
post #3

[flagged]

Where someone produces something is actually not that relevant for how/where taxes are paid. If you buy something in the US produced in China, the US gov still gets its money through sales tax / VAT, import fees etc. Is that parasitically extracting of value?

But for tech, this doesn't happen. Leaving a hole in tax system.

Re: Germany approves global minimum corporate tax

#12
They shouldn't be surprised if corporations leave their market. I'm philosophical about this. The world is moving toward smaller more fragmented economies. On the negative side, supply chains will have to adjust and the world economy will become less dynamic. On the plus side, local economic ecosystems will develop. Diversity.

Re: Germany approves global minimum corporate tax

#13
post #3

[flagged]

It's an OECD initiative, not an EU one.

Needs to be on top. All people that claim that this means companies will leave Germany forget that the whole OECD including the USA agreed to this. That‘s the global part in the title.

Re: Germany approves global minimum corporate tax

#14

They shouldn't be surprised if corporations leave their market. I'm philosophical about this. The world is moving toward smaller more fragmented economies. On the negative side, supply chains will have to adjust and the world economy will become less dynamic. On the plus side, local economic ecosystems will develop. Diversity.

> They shouldn't be surprised if corporations leave their market.

This is really just basic math. If your country isn't a larger percentage of their market than this would increase their global tax rate, staying in your country would cause them to lose money.

It's also not obvious how they would expect to enforce this, or prevent it from leading to restructuring. If a German company buys widgets from China for $9 and sells them for $10, 90% of the revenue is going to China, but the Chinese company has no operations in Germany. If that means the foreign company (and so 90% of the revenue) isn't subject to your jurisdiction, that's what everybody is going to do. If you try to collect the tax at the border, all you've done is switched to VAT and you might as well do it formally instead of doing something unnecessarily complicated but equivalent.

And it creates a new arbitrage opportunity where some country nominally taxes you at a particular rate but then you get the money back or some other equivalent value using whatever means causes it to not be considered taxable income.

Re: Germany approves global minimum corporate tax

#16

I hope they realise that every tax levied on a corporation will simply get passed on to the consumer eventually. I don't think these additional taxes make any sense along with a personal income tax. It should be one or the other.

The logical extension of this argument seems to be that the most consumer friendly policy would be to not tax corporations at all. I’m not sure I would agree with that.

Re: Germany approves global minimum corporate tax

#17

I hope they realise that every tax levied on a corporation will simply get passed on to the consumer eventually. I don't think these additional taxes make any sense along with a personal income tax. It should be one or the other.

> I hope they realise that every tax levied on a corporation will simply get passed on to the consumer eventually.

So it is impossible that the profit for owners/shareholders/etc. will sink instead of prices rising?

Re: Germany approves global minimum corporate tax

#18
post #3

[flagged]

Exports and imports of United States in 2021

The total value of exports (FoB) was 1,753,137 million. The total value of imports (CIF) was 2,932,976 million.

Overall Exports and Imports for European Union 2021

The total value of exports (FOB) is US$ 2,576,314 million. The total value of imports (CIF) is US$ 2,510,166 million.

I guess so?

Re: Germany approves global minimum corporate tax

#19

I hope they realise that every tax levied on a corporation will simply get passed on to the consumer eventually. I don't think these additional taxes make any sense along with a personal income tax. It should be one or the other.

In this case, it might not have that effect if it instead onshores money that would have been held in Ireland or Bermuda instead

Re: Germany approves global minimum corporate tax

#20

They shouldn't be surprised if corporations leave their market. I'm philosophical about this. The world is moving toward smaller more fragmented economies. On the negative side, supply chains will have to adjust and the world economy will become less dynamic. On the plus side, local economic ecosystems will develop. Diversity.

This is simply approval of an international treaty. Corporations would have to leave 140 markets to avoid it. https://taxfoundation.org/blog/global-tax-agreement/
Post reply on HN