Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft consumes Activision; and a plea

blog.zarfhome.com

11–20 of 163 posts

Re: Microsoft consumes Activision; and a plea

#11
post #7
post #5

Games made before I was born whose copyright won't expire until long after I'm dead. They ought to be public domain by now. In fact, games should have a shorter copyright term since they're harder to preserve and less valuable over time. I still have a box legally-purchased of Zork games (CDROM editions) and manuals and a copy of Planetfall here, but should I feel any shame about pirating them? I don't think I should…

> Games made before I was born whose copyright won't expire until long after I'm dead. Just like Mickey Mouse or movies from the 1960s? Or the Lord of the Rings books? > In fact, games should have a shorter copyright term since they're harder to preserve and less valuable over time. I don't understand how that's an argument for the length of the copyright either way? If I draw with water-colours on a fallen maple lea…

> I don't understand how that's an argument for the length of the copyright either way?

One argument might be that, compared to other media, video games' continued availability may be particularly dependent on whether or not they become public domain.

If video game hardware quickly becomes out of date and old games lose their economic value quickly, then the copyright holder may not be motivated to put in the effort to keep the game available.

However, an archivist motivated by artistic or historical rather than economic value may still be willing to put the effort into keeping the game available if it is in the public domain.

Re: Microsoft consumes Activision; and a plea

#12
post #7
post #5

Games made before I was born whose copyright won't expire until long after I'm dead. They ought to be public domain by now. In fact, games should have a shorter copyright term since they're harder to preserve and less valuable over time. I still have a box legally-purchased of Zork games (CDROM editions) and manuals and a copy of Planetfall here, but should I feel any shame about pirating them? I don't think I should…

> Games made before I was born whose copyright won't expire until long after I'm dead. Just like Mickey Mouse or movies from the 1960s? Or the Lord of the Rings books? > In fact, games should have a shorter copyright term since they're harder to preserve and less valuable over time. I don't understand how that's an argument for the length of the copyright either way? If I draw with water-colours on a fallen maple lea…

>Just like Mickey Mouse or movies from the 1960s? Or the Lord of the Rings books?

Yes? It's because of Disney that copyright laws are as ridiculous as they are.

Re: Microsoft consumes Activision; and a plea

#15

Zork for XBOX in 4K coming to Game Pass.

You know what, I'd play that!

Give me a new Zork story, great font, great music, I'd be all over it.

Obviously you'd chose actions from a list due to the controller, but with progressive disclosure you wouldn't really feel like cheating the game.

Re: Microsoft consumes Activision; and a plea

#16

Zork for XBOX in 4K coming to Game Pass.

I bet you could use some kind of generative AI to automatically render images of each scene from a text adventure.

this exists as a plugin for a popular MUD client (MUSHClient) already, it's pretty neat.

Re: Microsoft consumes Activision; and a plea

#17
post #5

Games made before I was born whose copyright won't expire until long after I'm dead. They ought to be public domain by now. In fact, games should have a shorter copyright term since they're harder to preserve and less valuable over time. I still have a box legally-purchased of Zork games (CDROM editions) and manuals and a copy of Planetfall here, but should I feel any shame about pirating them? I don't think I should…

All copyright is way too long but authors go completely off-piste at anyone who suggests that it should be something more reasonable (I kinda like 21 years myself).

Part of the issue is that the loudest voices are that 0.01% of authors whose work still has some commercial value decades after its creation.

Re: Microsoft consumes Activision; and a plea

#18
post #5

Games made before I was born whose copyright won't expire until long after I'm dead. They ought to be public domain by now. In fact, games should have a shorter copyright term since they're harder to preserve and less valuable over time. I still have a box legally-purchased of Zork games (CDROM editions) and manuals and a copy of Planetfall here, but should I feel any shame about pirating them? I don't think I should…

I've been meaning the finish return to zork for a while now. Tried to install it in scummvm with luck. I need to try it again so i can play in bed before going to sleep

Re: Microsoft consumes Activision; and a plea

#20

Zork for XBOX in 4K coming to Game Pass.

I bet you could use some kind of generative AI to automatically render images of each scene from a text adventure.

Somebody already did this for Zork though I can’t find the link at the moment. When I looked at it, it was interesting, but not particularly good. I’m sure it would get better in time.
Post reply on HN