Live data from Hacker News

Krita 5.2

krita.org

11–20 of 61 posts

Re: Krita 5.2

#11
post #4

I try Krita every now and then (probably will again with this release) but I always find myself going back to Clip Studio Paint at some point. The out of the box experience is just better somehow.

Krita shortcuts were not chosen by someone who draw. Why do you need 2 hands to rotate the view , one of my hand have the pen in it ?!?

From the release notes:

- Krita now have a Clip Studio Paint compatible shortcut scheme

Re: Krita 5.2

#12
post #4

I try Krita every now and then (probably will again with this release) but I always find myself going back to Clip Studio Paint at some point. The out of the box experience is just better somehow.

Krita shortcuts were not chosen by someone who draw. Why do you need 2 hands to rotate the view , one of my hand have the pen in it ?!?

I don't know if it helps your issue, but this latest update does include a set of Clip Studio Paint compatible key bindings.

Re: Krita 5.2

#13

I try Krita every now and then (probably will again with this release) but I always find myself going back to Clip Studio Paint at some point. The out of the box experience is just better somehow.

It's limited vector painting tools are what keep me in Clip Studio. It's the first thing I look for with each Krita release.

I suspect it's probably going to be a while unfortunately. I'm all-in on Open Source, there's no way I'm moving back to CSP, but the lack of vector drawing in Krita has driven me to learn more about Blender grease pencil. It's got both some really amazing features and some frustrating limitations as well.

Truthfully, CSP is also not quite everything I would want out of vector tools, it's just closer. What I've been interested in for a while and haven't been able to replicate is drawing in multiple passes: draw a stroke's position, then its thickness, then its strength, then its velocity, all as separate steps.

CSP sort of has this; you can redraw vector strokes (or at least could last time I used it), and it was great. But I feel like it could be taken further and I feel like it's an area where there could be a lot of innovation beyond what CSP even allows. But I don't think there's consensus yet from the Krita team about what direction they would want to go, and to be fair, I'm not sure I would be able to answer that question either. I'm not sure just copying CSP would be the right move, I do want to see more actual experimentation in that space beyond just vector layers -- like ideally I'd like to be able to do multiple-pass strokes in paint layers too?

But it is a really big weakness of the app right now, I agree.

Re: Krita 5.2

#14
post #4

I try Krita every now and then (probably will again with this release) but I always find myself going back to Clip Studio Paint at some point. The out of the box experience is just better somehow.

Krita shortcuts were not chosen by someone who draw. Why do you need 2 hands to rotate the view , one of my hand have the pen in it ?!?

It's tough to judge because I'm not familiar with the shortcuts anymore but around the time that CSP swapped to the subscription model (or however it works) Krita devs started implementing a CSP mode that changes the default shortcuts to try and match.

I don't know how close it actually is though.

Re: Krita 5.2

#15
post #5

Will have to check it out to see if it has my most-longed-for feature. The ability to nudge the selection by a single pixel with the arrow keys.

I'm not familiar with the project but this sounds like a good first contribution, if you want to get involved as a developer :)

Re: Krita 5.2

#17
post #11
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Krita shortcuts were not chosen by someone who draw. Why do you need 2 hands to rotate the view , one of my hand have the pen in it ?!?

From the release notes: - Krita now have a Clip Studio Paint compatible shortcut scheme

Wait, is that only now? I'm kind of confused, maybe I've been on a beta branch or something, I could of sworn that was part of 5.1?

You're right, I'm looking at the release notes now. But it's a very weird deja vu moment. There are a couple of features listed here that I really thought were already released. I need to check what my upstream is...

Re: Krita 5.2

#19
post #15
post #5

Will have to check it out to see if it has my most-longed-for feature. The ability to nudge the selection by a single pixel with the arrow keys.

I'm not familiar with the project but this sounds like a good first contribution, if you want to get involved as a developer :)

Make sure to hit up their IRC first, the friendly folks there will put you into the right path. Krita will always be special for me because I’ve put in a feature that I use all the time. So it will become special for you as well.

Re: Krita 5.2

#20
I found it difficult to get started with Krita because it doesn't automatically pan when you try to draw beyond the edge of the current view when using a drawing tablet. I wrote about it on https://krita-artists.org/t/how-can-you-have-automatic-panni... a couple of months ago and now filed an issue at https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=475481 after observing the same behavior in 5.2

Any chance of seeing this feature request in future releases?

For everyone who has a hard time with the keyboard shortcuts I recommend https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eiP7pXnwu6g which covers basic navigation in 1 minute.

Post reply on HN