Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

OCI container of OBS Studio with 50 plugins included

github.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–19 of 19 posts

Re: OCI container of OBS Studio with 50 plugins included

#11

Post by flexiondotorg »

colonelpopcorn wrote: post #3
verdverm wrote: post #2

This looks really nice with all the bundled plugins. I'm about to rebuild my streaming setup and move away from streamlabs. Some questions... Can I dual stream to YouTube and twitch? Could this work from a kvm setup, allowing me to capture windows from both nested, or windows from Linux? Might also see what's possible via termina/chromeos

There's a great write up on how to proxy/multiplex rtmp streams with nginx on the OBS forums. https://obsproject.com/forum/resources/obs-studio-stream-to-... Edit: That one is newer and maybe more useful. Here's the one I had used before. https://obsproject.com/forum/resources/how-to-set-up-your-ow...

That is a nifty solution

Re: OCI container of OBS Studio with 50 plugins included

#12

Post by kevincox »

dannyobrien wrote: post #5

Wow! This is great! It was always such a struggle to get stuff like CEF (necessary to show rendered HTML/web pages and chat in a livestream) on Linux. I never even tried to tackle other plugins. I might start up my livecoding again based on this -- thank you

Is OBS packaged by your distro? On NixOS I just started up OBS and I could add the "Browser" input with no issues.

Re: OCI container of OBS Studio with 50 plugins included

#13

Post by flexiondotorg »

kevincox wrote: post #12
dannyobrien wrote: post #5

Wow! This is great! It was always such a struggle to get stuff like CEF (necessary to show rendered HTML/web pages and chat in a livestream) on Linux. I never even tried to tackle other plugins. I might start up my livecoding again based on this -- thank you

Is OBS packaged by your distro? On NixOS I just started up OBS and I could add the "Browser" input with no issues.

This OBS Studio Portable container is built with Ubuntu, because Ubuntu is one of the supported Linux targets by upstream OBS. The OBS Studio Portable container is a ready-to-run, batteries included turn-key solution.

I am a NixOS user and nixpkgs maintainer. I've been working on adding more OBS plugins to nixpkgs and fixing OBS Studio in nixpkgs, but it needs more work:

- For me, it is missing some plugins I rely on and some of the OBS plugins in nixpkgs do not work. I am actively working on this.

- FDK ACC doesn't work in OBS in nixpkgs and the ffmpeg version is not fully API compatible with OBS, meaning some presets do not work. On my list to fix.

- CEF in nixpkgs is not ABI compatible with OBS and cause OBS to segfault when authenticating Twitch. Again, on my list of things to fix.

I have a long history of building a custom OBS Studio on Ubuntu, so decided to make this OBS Studio container with my friends in the Universal Blue project, to get myself a complete OBS setup I can use on NixOS while I continue to work on OBS related fixes in nixpkgs :-)

Re: OCI container of OBS Studio with 50 plugins included

#14

Post by verdverm »

flexiondotorg wrote: post #9
verdverm wrote: post #2

This looks really nice with all the bundled plugins. I'm about to rebuild my streaming setup and move away from streamlabs. Some questions... Can I dual stream to YouTube and twitch? Could this work from a kvm setup, allowing me to capture windows from both nested, or windows from Linux? Might also see what's possible via termina/chromeos

I've been streaming this way for a while now. Yes, you can dual stream. - I do this using livepush.io. So one stream out to livepush and they push to multiple services. - However you could run multiple instances of this container and have each stream to a different service. For example one container being the main streaming setup that streams to Twitch but also has NDI or Teleport output that can then be ingested via…

> Using this is KVM is technically possible but you'd lose a load of the benefits of running in a container

Not understanding why this would hold true, kvm and containers are both virtualization like tools, just at different levels. I think the main hold up would be the lack of many typical OS features. Like not sure how you'd go about setting up GStreamer for this OBS setup

> Can ChromeOS running Podman and Distrobox? If so, it should work fine.

Pretty much any container, and more than one at a time. Better than WSL imho

https://www.reddit.com/r/Crostini/comments/9yds5p/how_to_run...

Re: OCI container of OBS Studio with 50 plugins included

#15

Post by flexiondotorg »

verdverm wrote: post #14
flexiondotorg wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been streaming this way for a while now. Yes, you can dual stream. - I do this using livepush.io. So one stream out to livepush and they push to multiple services. - However you could run multiple instances of this container and have each stream to a different service. For example one container being the main streaming setup that streams to Twitch but also has NDI or Teleport output that can then be ingested via…

> Using this is KVM is technically possible but you'd lose a load of the benefits of running in a container Not understanding why this would hold true, kvm and containers are both virtualization like tools, just at different levels. I think the main hold up would be the lack of many typical OS features. Like not sure how you'd go about setting up GStreamer for this OBS setup > Can ChromeOS running Podman and Distrobo…

Passing through a GPU to a kernel in a VM requires fiddling with SR-IOV and IOMMU, which also requires your hardware is compatible. Often hardware is not compatible, either by design because these features are artificially reserved for "enterprise" models or due to accidental IOMMU group conflicts on lower priced motherboards.

As containers share the host kernel, these issues do not arise and hardware acceleration is trivial.

Re: OCI container of OBS Studio with 50 plugins included

#16

Post by genpfault »

> The Open Container Initiative (OCI) is a Linux Foundation project, started in June 2015 by Docker, CoreOS, and the maintainers of appc to design open standards for operating-system-level virtualization (software containers). At launch, OCI was focused on Linux containers and subsequent work has extended it to other operating systems.[1]

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Container_Initiative

Re: OCI container of OBS Studio with 50 plugins included

#17

Post by qingcharles »

dannyobrien wrote: post #5

Wow! This is great! It was always such a struggle to get stuff like CEF (necessary to show rendered HTML/web pages and chat in a livestream) on Linux. I never even tried to tackle other plugins. I might start up my livecoding again based on this -- thank you

Danny! God, I remember your TV show, 404 Not Found. You should restart that. Did you film it at Capital? I was doing Chips with Everything for .tv at the same time in that tiny, tiny studio.

I was in court testifying about something technical recently and the prosecutor said "And where did you get that?" and I said "404 Not Found" and it was very confusing for them.

Re: OCI container of OBS Studio with 50 plugins included

#18

Post by qingcharles »

molesy wrote: post #8
verdverm wrote: post #2

This looks really nice with all the bundled plugins. I'm about to rebuild my streaming setup and move away from streamlabs. Some questions... Can I dual stream to YouTube and twitch? Could this work from a kvm setup, allowing me to capture windows from both nested, or windows from Linux? Might also see what's possible via termina/chromeos

> Can I dual stream to YouTube and twitch? Technically yes, but it's against Twitch's ToS as of June: https://help.twitch.tv/s/article/simulcasting-guidelines?lan...

Wow, I never knew this, thank you. It's also bullshit. I get why they're doing it, but I don't like it.

Re: OCI container of OBS Studio with 50 plugins included

#19

Post by funcDropShadow »

flexiondotorg wrote: post #13
kevincox wrote: post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is OBS packaged by your distro? On NixOS I just started up OBS and I could add the "Browser" input with no issues.

This OBS Studio Portable container is built with Ubuntu, because Ubuntu is one of the supported Linux targets by upstream OBS. The OBS Studio Portable container is a ready-to-run, batteries included turn-key solution. I am a NixOS user and nixpkgs maintainer. I've been working on adding more OBS plugins to nixpkgs and fixing OBS Studio in nixpkgs, but it needs more work: - For me, it is missing some plugins I rely on…

Thanks for your work.
Post reply on HN