Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

The First 6 Books of the Elements of Euclid with Coloured Diagrams and Symbols

c82.net

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–15 of 15 posts

Re: The First 6 Books of the Elements of Euclid with Coloured Diagrams and Symbols

#11

Post by steppi »

gota wrote: post #9
itishappy wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's an old book: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cf/Title_pa...

I know it's an old book. I have several copies in multiple languages a couple of meters from where I'm sitting. None of them have colored designs or interactive elements, so I really struggle to understand your point

Oliver Byrne’s 1847 edition of the elements did have colored designs [0]. This website features a digitization of Byrne’s book and defaults to the text as it appears in the original.

[0] https://maa.org/press/periodicals/convergence/mathematical-t...

Re: The First 6 Books of the Elements of Euclid with Coloured Diagrams and Symbols

#12

Post by itishappy »

gota wrote: post #9
itishappy wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's an old book: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cf/Title_pa...

I know it's an old book. I have several copies in multiple languages a couple of meters from where I'm sitting. None of them have colored designs or interactive elements, so I really struggle to understand your point

> None of them have colored designs or interactive elements

Euclid didn't include interactivity? Seems like a bit of an oversight.

Anyway, that wasn't the question. Check out the S's on that cover.

Re: The First 6 Books of the Elements of Euclid with Coloured Diagrams and Symbols

#13

Post by itishappy »

gota wrote: post #10
aragonite wrote: post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a reproduction of Oliver Byrne's 1847 edition, which uses the long s. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:First_six_bo...

Seems like a weird choice to make it colored, interactive etc. - presumably to maximize accessibility/digestibility by laymen - and then adopt an outdated typography choice for coherence with a 180 year old edition

The colors and the weird s were both from the 180 year old version. The interactivity is new. Here's the author's thoughts:

> Creating a faithful online reproduction of a book considered one of the most beautiful and unusual publications ever published is a daunting task. Byrne’s Euclid is my tribute to Oliver Byrne’s most celebrated publication from 1847 that illustrated the geometric principles established in Euclid’s original Elements from 300 BC.

> The long s (ſ) was common in older publications and is used throughout the book. Even though it’s commonly mistaken for the lowercase f, I felt reproducing it was also important to stay true to the original.

> I wanted to add interactivity to the diagrams to aid in understanding them because I had some trouble understanding some in the original book.

Here's lots more thoughts:

https://www.c82.net/blog/?id=79

Re: The First 6 Books of the Elements of Euclid with Coloured Diagrams and Symbols

#14

Post by dexwiz »

thunkle wrote: post #3

Is it just my phone or are all the "s"s and "f"s accidently mathematical notation on the first book.

I have this book in print and that is my main complaint. It explains the typographical history and I get it…but it still makes it harder to read than necessary.
Post reply on HN