Live data from Hacker News

iPhone 15’s shift to USB-C

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 117 posts

Re: iPhone 15’s shift to USB-C

#11

It also has the potential to be quite confusing. There will almost certainly be some laptops that attempt to charge themselves from the iPhone battery depending on which of the 10 versions of USB-C are being implemented. Will all the counterfeit usb-c cables also cause a bunch of confusion when features don’t work? Will plugging in your phone at the airport be less of a risk?

Apple will gladly sell you a 100% compatible cable for $20, just like they do with lightning.

Re: iPhone 15’s shift to USB-C

#12
post #9

Apple would cannibalize their computer and iPad sales if they were supporting the thin client model like Samsung DeX. See how they already avoid cannibalization of the iPhone business by preventing the iPad to make phone calls. They protect their product lines from each other. As much as I like to see such a feature, I don’t think Apple will ever give it to us.

Which is a very sad conclusion because Steve Jobs was very explicit that they had to cannibalize their own products or someone else would.

Re: iPhone 15’s shift to USB-C

#13
post #5

How does the author make the logical leap from "it'll use Type C" to "it'll have Samsung DeX equivalent"? I think it's too much of a gimmick for Apple to even try, plus Apple is really not known for giving a damn about making their products work well with third-party peripherals.

[flagged]

Re: iPhone 15’s shift to USB-C

#14

If Apple wanted to make the iPhone a computer replacement, and all that was holding them back was USB-C, they would have added it in a long time ago. They didn’t. They waited until the EU made them switch to USB-C.

They don't even want to make iPad a computer replacement. Half of the models have a M-class chip powering them.

Re: iPhone 15’s shift to USB-C

#15
>An iPhone that’s able to project something more like iPadOS (or, ideally, but not definitely wishful thinking on my part — macOS) when connected to a screen could easily replace a laptop for probably a significant portion of the population, including for casual computing, and for the work tasks of the bulk of the knowledge workforce.

No, it wouldn't, because you'd need a display and input device(s) at your destination. So then we ended up with these laptop-style shells for Android and Windows Phone devices that supported this model and suddenly you can't use your phone separately while you're in laptop mode. It's easier to just bring a laptop/Chromebook with you.

There's no need for the device's local storage when you're already syncing important documents to the cloud anyway. This is a "cool" solution in search of a problem.

Re: iPhone 15’s shift to USB-C

#16
post #9

Apple would cannibalize their computer and iPad sales if they were supporting the thin client model like Samsung DeX. See how they already avoid cannibalization of the iPhone business by preventing the iPad to make phone calls. They protect their product lines from each other. As much as I like to see such a feature, I don’t think Apple will ever give it to us.

Which is a very sad conclusion because Steve Jobs was very explicit that they had to cannibalize their own products or someone else would.

There are things people say and then there are things people do

Re: iPhone 15’s shift to USB-C

#17
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which is a very sad conclusion because Steve Jobs was very explicit that they had to cannibalize their own products or someone else would.

There are things people say and then there are things people do

Steve Jobs is dead.

Re: iPhone 15’s shift to USB-C

#18
post #9

Apple would cannibalize their computer and iPad sales if they were supporting the thin client model like Samsung DeX. See how they already avoid cannibalization of the iPhone business by preventing the iPad to make phone calls. They protect their product lines from each other. As much as I like to see such a feature, I don’t think Apple will ever give it to us.

See also: cellular Apple Watch unable to make calls/texts without being tethered (over an Internet connection, remotely!) to an iPhone.

Re: iPhone 15’s shift to USB-C

#19
post #15

>An iPhone that’s able to project something more like iPadOS (or, ideally, but not definitely wishful thinking on my part — macOS) when connected to a screen could easily replace a laptop for probably a significant portion of the population, including for casual computing, and for the work tasks of the bulk of the knowledge workforce. No, it wouldn't, because you'd need a display and input device(s) at your destinati…

The problem is having too many devices. Most people should just need a phone that can also serve as a personal computer. A personal laptop is a hassle, remember we already have a work computer provided by our employers

Re: iPhone 15’s shift to USB-C

#20
post #15

>An iPhone that’s able to project something more like iPadOS (or, ideally, but not definitely wishful thinking on my part — macOS) when connected to a screen could easily replace a laptop for probably a significant portion of the population, including for casual computing, and for the work tasks of the bulk of the knowledge workforce. No, it wouldn't, because you'd need a display and input device(s) at your destinati…

> There's no need for the device's local storage when you're already syncing important documents to the cloud anyway

Syncing to the cloud is a pain, requires an internet connection, etc. If I could just carry everything around on a personal device and leave the cloud as backup only I would love that.

Post reply on HN