Live data from Hacker News

Landlords Are Pushing the Supreme Court to End Rent Control

jacobin.com

11–20 of 81 posts

Re: Landlords Are Pushing the Supreme Court to End Rent Control

#11

Rent control is dumb policy anyways. Now how can we get rid of nimby rule? Local governments have way too much influence on development, for better or worse. Perhaps sufficiently large development proposals must be entertained by the entire city or town rather than being unilaterally decided by a board - that seems like a sufficient compromise (at the expense of speed, but development is slow anyway given the appeals…

[flagged]

Re: Landlords Are Pushing the Supreme Court to End Rent Control

#12

Rent control is dumb policy anyways. Now how can we get rid of nimby rule? Local governments have way too much influence on development, for better or worse. Perhaps sufficiently large development proposals must be entertained by the entire city or town rather than being unilaterally decided by a board - that seems like a sufficient compromise (at the expense of speed, but development is slow anyway given the appeals…

[flagged]

So the government should serve the interests of those that aren’t residents to the detriment of those that do?

Re: Landlords Are Pushing the Supreme Court to End Rent Control

#15

Rent control is dumb policy anyways. Now how can we get rid of nimby rule? Local governments have way too much influence on development, for better or worse. Perhaps sufficiently large development proposals must be entertained by the entire city or town rather than being unilaterally decided by a board - that seems like a sufficient compromise (at the expense of speed, but development is slow anyway given the appeals…

[flagged]

> Remove planning rights from local/city government entirely

> You must use the government to essentially take land and repurpose it.

Which government? In your first sentence we removed land planning from the local government.

Re: Landlords Are Pushing the Supreme Court to End Rent Control

#16

Rent control is dumb policy anyways. Now how can we get rid of nimby rule? Local governments have way too much influence on development, for better or worse. Perhaps sufficiently large development proposals must be entertained by the entire city or town rather than being unilaterally decided by a board - that seems like a sufficient compromise (at the expense of speed, but development is slow anyway given the appeals…

You know why the local government is the best government? It's the government I can fire through voting. If the state had more power my votes would also have more power to change my community.

I don't mean to imply abolishing the federal government in favor of local government. Just a redistribution of power that favors the local government more than the current status quo.

Re: Landlords Are Pushing the Supreme Court to End Rent Control

#17

Rent control is dumb policy anyways. Now how can we get rid of nimby rule? Local governments have way too much influence on development, for better or worse. Perhaps sufficiently large development proposals must be entertained by the entire city or town rather than being unilaterally decided by a board - that seems like a sufficient compromise (at the expense of speed, but development is slow anyway given the appeals…

Why don't we get rid of NIMBYism and make sure that actually solves the issue without banning sensible implementations of rent control?

Rent control is a bad policy no matter how you slice it. In general most price controls are counterproductive

Re: Landlords Are Pushing the Supreme Court to End Rent Control

#19

Rent control is dumb policy anyways. Now how can we get rid of nimby rule? Local governments have way too much influence on development, for better or worse. Perhaps sufficiently large development proposals must be entertained by the entire city or town rather than being unilaterally decided by a board - that seems like a sufficient compromise (at the expense of speed, but development is slow anyway given the appeals…

You know why the local government is the best government? It's the government I can fire through voting. If the state had more power my votes would also have more power to change my community. I don't mean to imply abolishing the federal government in favor of local government. Just a redistribution of power that favors the local government more than the current status quo.

I’m not sure what your point is.

Re: Landlords Are Pushing the Supreme Court to End Rent Control

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why don't we get rid of NIMBYism and make sure that actually solves the issue without banning sensible implementations of rent control?

Rent control is a bad policy no matter how you slice it. In general most price controls are counterproductive

For many people, price gouging is conceptually palatable when it doesn't apply to them.

A revision would make more sense, but treating it like a black and white issue is disingenuous.

Post reply on HN