Live data from Hacker News

Annual EFF Awards: Alexandra Elbakyan, Library Freedom Project, and Signal

eff.org

11–20 of 43 posts

Re: Annual EFF Awards: Alexandra Elbakyan, Library Freedom Project, and Signal

#11

No awards for Mozilla? EFF should really award Mozilla for keeping up with web standards using their own browser engine instead of just being Chromium copycat.

Mozilla were the 2008 Pioneer Awards winner, along with CEO Mitchell Baker: https://web.archive.org/web/20100407220831/https://www.eff.o...>

Full list of past winners: https://www.eff.org/awards/past-winners>

Re: Annual EFF Awards: Alexandra Elbakyan, Library Freedom Project, and Signal

#12

One of the most important factors in changing laws and confronting oppressive forces is to create strong popular awareness and support for those opposing them. Among other things, this makes them far more risky and formidible as targets of opportunity for oppressors . In this sense I hope very much that the cyberrights movement is maturing to recognise that technical means of fighting such oppression are, whilst nece…

I think history will remember Alexandra Elbakyan as one of the most important figures of this century. She's very low-profile, but the work she's doing is of fundamental importance to humanity. Locking (usually publicly-funded) scientific knowledge behind obscenely-expensive paywalls is repugnant and should be criminal.

Re: Annual EFF Awards: Alexandra Elbakyan, Library Freedom Project, and Signal

#13
post #6

Earlier this week it was a Wired hit piece telling us Signal is full of alt-right boogymen and naziquadroons. Now they're the champions of digital freedom. I'm gonna have whiplash!

https://www.wired.com/story/signal-politics-software-critici...

Re: Annual EFF Awards: Alexandra Elbakyan, Library Freedom Project, and Signal

#17

I'm not sure Elbakyan receiving this award is particularly appropriate, considering she is strongly pro-Putin and is a big fan of Joseph Stalin (she regularly quotes him on VK).

I hate Stalin and severely dislike Putin.

I respect Elbakyan a lot and her contributions have benefited hundreds of thousands of people.

And we should not practice cancel culture when recognizing contributions of people.

Re: Annual EFF Awards: Alexandra Elbakyan, Library Freedom Project, and Signal

#18

I'm not sure Elbakyan receiving this award is particularly appropriate, considering she is strongly pro-Putin and is a big fan of Joseph Stalin (she regularly quotes him on VK).

As I told my kid at supper tonight, words are meaningless, people judge you on your actions.

And Elbakyan's actions the past decade are commendable.

Re: Annual EFF Awards: Alexandra Elbakyan, Library Freedom Project, and Signal

#19

[flagged]

-Elbakyan's actions are directly against private gatekeepers of publicly-funded knowledge

-Signal is an alternative to the messaging apps that hoover up all your data.

Not sure about that 3rd org but I'll be sure to look them up

Re: Annual EFF Awards: Alexandra Elbakyan, Library Freedom Project, and Signal

#20
post #6

Earlier this week it was a Wired hit piece telling us Signal is full of alt-right boogymen and naziquadroons. Now they're the champions of digital freedom. I'm gonna have whiplash!

Are you talking about the Wired piece linked by smartbit ?

If so this seems like an unfair summary given the piece is very long, the first half sings technical praise, the second half laments the challenges faced, and there's one single small paragraph (that I saw) that mentions some Signal users as possible boogymen:

    The company’s aggressive pursuit of growth, coupled with lack of moderation in the app, has already led Signal employees themselves to publicly question whether growth might come from abusive users, such as far-right groups using Signal to organize.
which seems more of a cautionary note rather than a hit piece.
Post reply on HN