Live data from Hacker News

GitHub profile achievements

cqcumbers.com

11–20 of 74 posts

Re: GitHub profile achievements

#11

The "This is fine" achievement is funny but doesn't seem right. The top user ppdemo indeed has a repo where he apparently creates one issue every minute, but there's only a few open issues so he must be deleting them too: https://github.com/pddemo/demo

It looks like it reads the number of issues ever created, and subtracts the number of issues tagged as "closed". So "deleted" in that dataset counts as "open".

Re: GitHub profile achievements

#12
Most of the toplists are just filled with spambots/automations/etc. Also, at least my pov, could this be a quite funny project if better measurements would have been taken. Autoscraping is always a good idea but why not turn it arround and call it a competition. Make people commit their info via a github app to place them in the different rankings and also a global one.

Alot of people always want to compete and present theirsel so it should drive itself if spread at the right places. Also you cann add monthyl rankings and stats with persisting medals to earn and keep on the profile page kinda linke a trophy shelf.

From here on you can just go the full gamification route with levelling etc.

glhf

Re: GitHub profile achievements

#14

Most of the toplists are just filled with spambots/automations/etc. Also, at least my pov, could this be a quite funny project if better measurements would have been taken. Autoscraping is always a good idea but why not turn it arround and call it a competition. Make people commit their info via a github app to place them in the different rankings and also a global one. Alot of people always want to compete and prese…

[deleted]

Re: GitHub profile achievements

#17
post #13

Why does everyone want to turn github in to gamified social media. The resulting software is the achievement not sone bullshit badge.

because these achievements are potentially interesting metadata about your work.

no one writes software for metadata. people write software, they push it to GitHub, and GitHub gives them achievements which may provide a fraction of a second of amusement.

let people enjoy themselves a little, sheesh.

Re: GitHub profile achievements

#18

Why does every little inconsequential thing have to be gamified to increase engagement? I couldn't care less about how many stars, arctic vault badges etc. do I get in a thing I use to hedge risk of losing my code and collaborate with others.

you're free to not care. most don't care. but achievements are not the goal, achievements are a fraction of a second of amusement or pride about a career of work.

it's not for you, fine. why complain about it? let people enjoy something even though you see no point for crying out loud.

Re: GitHub profile achievements

#19
Someone makes a joke post with parody github achievements. Someone else then uses a public dataset to see how many people have these parody achievement.

Hacker News: "Gamifying everything is terrible"

I think getting angry about everything including parody github achievements is terrible.

Re: GitHub profile achievements

#20
post #13

Why does everyone want to turn github in to gamified social media. The resulting software is the achievement not sone bullshit badge.

Awards are powerfully gratifying and motivational, for some of us especially so. Symbolism is present in every civilization of every era for a reason.
Post reply on HN