Live data from Hacker News

Reddit founders made hundreds of fake profiles so site looked popular (2012)

arstechnica.com

11–20 of 42 posts

Re: Reddit founders made hundreds of fake profiles so site looked popular (2012)

#11
post #7

I've been considering using Reddit data to pre-seed the content in a successor to Reddit. Though I am unsure how that would stand legally. As a side note, I created an alternative Reddit API[1] and Reddit didn't like that so much they banned my 13 year old Reddit account. 1 - https://api.reddiw.com

Just launder it through an LLM, problem solved.

Indeed. Could call it something like the RedditCrawl corpus.

Re: Reddit founders made hundreds of fake profiles so site looked popular (2012)

#15
post #7

I've been considering using Reddit data to pre-seed the content in a successor to Reddit. Though I am unsure how that would stand legally. As a side note, I created an alternative Reddit API[1] and Reddit didn't like that so much they banned my 13 year old Reddit account. 1 - https://api.reddiw.com

IANAL. For the US, users grant Reddit a license to use their content when they post it. The users still own that content. Reddit's license does not extend to your reuse of it[0], nor have the underlying users directly granted you permission, so it would not be legal (in the US) for you to reuse like that.

[0] "you may not... license, sell, transfer, assign, distribute, host, or otherwise commercially exploit the Services or Content" https://www.redditinc.com/policies/user-agreement-september-...

Re: Reddit founders made hundreds of fake profiles so site looked popular (2012)

#17
post #7

I've been considering using Reddit data to pre-seed the content in a successor to Reddit. Though I am unsure how that would stand legally. As a side note, I created an alternative Reddit API[1] and Reddit didn't like that so much they banned my 13 year old Reddit account. 1 - https://api.reddiw.com

Having first rephrased it all via Chat GPT.

Load up those liabilities.

Re: Reddit founders made hundreds of fake profiles so site looked popular (2012)

#18

Many small startups generate fake traffic, either for testing or for marketing purposes (e.g. cheating on the numbers). I would be surprised to find any successful company that had no shenanigans in their origin story. My history included a startup that shipped empty boxes to meet numbers, scraped thousands of emails from more popular websites to sell as their own traffic, even one that forged stock certificates to s…

Well, it definitely goes against the economic propaganda that the US fed the rest of the world, that you can become wealthy by hard and honest entrepreneurship.

Re: Reddit founders made hundreds of fake profiles so site looked popular (2012)

#19

Many small startups generate fake traffic, either for testing or for marketing purposes (e.g. cheating on the numbers). I would be surprised to find any successful company that had no shenanigans in their origin story. My history included a startup that shipped empty boxes to meet numbers, scraped thousands of emails from more popular websites to sell as their own traffic, even one that forged stock certificates to s…

LinkedIn famously abused oauth permissions to take over the email accounts of their users and send invites to their service to the contact list.

Please don’t normalize this. Just because it has many famous examples does not mean it should ever become socially acceptable. Fuck every company that has done this.

Re: Reddit founders made hundreds of fake profiles so site looked popular (2012)

#20
post #7

I've been considering using Reddit data to pre-seed the content in a successor to Reddit. Though I am unsure how that would stand legally. As a side note, I created an alternative Reddit API[1] and Reddit didn't like that so much they banned my 13 year old Reddit account. 1 - https://api.reddiw.com

I was chatting about this with some friends. If we had a million or so spare, just fork Reddit. Grab the latest open source version of Reddit, pay the pushshift guys for the most up-to-date dump they have and get it in.

Make a system for claiming your old Reddit account. I'm guessing if you try to use OAuth, Reddit will just ban you. So you need to get creative, probably make an extension that grabs the users sessionid from their cookies or something (or let people copypaste it in if they are technical enough).

Fun to imagine but unfortunately probably won't happen.

Post reply on HN