Live data from Hacker News

ReactOS – A free Windows-compatible Operating System

github.com

11–20 of 39 posts

Re: ReactOS – A free Windows-compatible Operating System

#11

More than 10 years, i'm waiting a installable ReactOS version, not virtualized. I don't thinks it will be one day...

I wonder if one of these would work for you. It's not the same as a normal installer, but you should be able to migrate out once you're installed.

https://askubuntu.com/questions/32499/migrate-from-a-virtual...

Re: ReactOS – A free Windows-compatible Operating System

#12
I was invited to join the ReactOS project about 10-12 years ago. I was part of it for, say, four days, then I left. I realized I could format my system drive with no warning or error. Then did a code review and realized that this project will never fly. I appreciate the motivation and goals, but I don't think you'll ever see a usable release of ReactOS. I am not against ReactOS, but the guys have way too few resources to ever be able to compete against Microsoft.

Re: ReactOS – A free Windows-compatible Operating System

#13

I was invited to join the ReactOS project about 10-12 years ago. I was part of it for, say, four days, then I left. I realized I could format my system drive with no warning or error. Then did a code review and realized that this project will never fly. I appreciate the motivation and goals, but I don't think you'll ever see a usable release of ReactOS. I am not against ReactOS, but the guys have way too few resource…

Isn't it a bit ironic that you left the project because it had too few resources?

Re: ReactOS – A free Windows-compatible Operating System

#14
post #7

"ReactOS™ is an Open Source effort to develop a quality operating system that is compatible with applications and drivers written for the Microsoft® Windows™ NT family of operating systems (NT4, 2000, XP, 2003, Vista, 7). The ReactOS project, although currently focused on Windows Server 2003 compatibility, is always keeping an eye toward compatibility with Windows Vista and future Windows NT releases." I always felt…

More and more software has quickly lost XP compatibility. I'm already finding myself struggling to download software I want to try on ReactOS itself because modern browsers are essentially unsupported. If it wants to remain relevant, it'll need SOME Windows 7 APIs at least. It doesn't need full compatibility like I think it should with older releases, but it needs to be compatible enough to run a few nice to haves as…

Not necessarily useful/suitable for use in ReactOS, but there are a few modified "recent" browsers that do work (mostly) on XP.

Mind you it's a mess of various browsers and versions and modified ones and patches to the modified ones, but if you are interested, here is a good entry point to the rabbit hole:

https://msfn.org/board/forum/201-browsers-working-on-older-n...

Re: ReactOS – A free Windows-compatible Operating System

#15

I was invited to join the ReactOS project about 10-12 years ago. I was part of it for, say, four days, then I left. I realized I could format my system drive with no warning or error. Then did a code review and realized that this project will never fly. I appreciate the motivation and goals, but I don't think you'll ever see a usable release of ReactOS. I am not against ReactOS, but the guys have way too few resource…

> the guys have way too few resources to ever be able to compete against Microsoft

Really? Are you absolutely sure, Sherlock? Did you know that the water is wet already or are you going to announce that in your next comment? ;)

The project has many other reasons-to-be and it would probably be very hard to find anyone seriously believing that "competing against Microsoft" is one of them.

Re: ReactOS – A free Windows-compatible Operating System

#17
post #13

I was invited to join the ReactOS project about 10-12 years ago. I was part of it for, say, four days, then I left. I realized I could format my system drive with no warning or error. Then did a code review and realized that this project will never fly. I appreciate the motivation and goals, but I don't think you'll ever see a usable release of ReactOS. I am not against ReactOS, but the guys have way too few resource…

Isn't it a bit ironic that you left the project because it had too few resources?

I suppose that’s the chicken and egg problem of wanting to participate in something that you think will / has a chance to go where you hope it will.

Re: ReactOS – A free Windows-compatible Operating System

#19

I was invited to join the ReactOS project about 10-12 years ago. I was part of it for, say, four days, then I left. I realized I could format my system drive with no warning or error. Then did a code review and realized that this project will never fly. I appreciate the motivation and goals, but I don't think you'll ever see a usable release of ReactOS. I am not against ReactOS, but the guys have way too few resource…

They don't need to be able to compete. But they need to be able to keep up with the moving target that is "Windows on which you can run applications that many people want to run". And they don't have the resources for even that.

Re: ReactOS – A free Windows-compatible Operating System

#20

More than 10 years, i'm waiting a installable ReactOS version, not virtualized. I don't thinks it will be one day...

It's mostly because bootstrapping code depends heavily on the target code, and while the target system code is changing often, committing to an installer architecture would be a serious hindrance to the architects' productivity on the core
Post reply on HN