Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Has anyone here had their jobs affected by AI in a negative way yet?

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–17 of 17 posts

Re: Has anyone here had their jobs affected by AI in a negative way yet?

#11

Post by quickthrower2 »

RollAHardSix wrote: post #10

Personally, I am terrified. I am doing GRC (Governance, Risk Management, Compliance) for a Marketing and PR Firm that is really just a digital marketing firm-- and we have already been told from industry insiders we can't bill over 70 dollars an hour for writers and expect to get the contract. I think AI has a very strong possibility of completely wrecking this industry and will allow either major marketing firms or…

It will wreck it from both sides: marketer get paid less, and the new marketing word soup will be drivel. If your marketing can be done by AI that isn't AGI then it will just suck. Subtly suck. Sort of a uncanny hill (looks good to the boss, but silently bores the audiences). Might be good for SEO though, to get some cost effective pseudo-advertising via. Google organic search.

Re: Has anyone here had their jobs affected by AI in a negative way yet?

#12

Post by quickthrower2 »

softwaredoug wrote: post #3

In the context of layoffs, I feel like junior software engineers have been indirectly impacted by AI. There's seemingly a lot of demand for senior talent and much less for junior talent. I imagine at least some of this would be caused by real or imagined productivity gains from AI tools for coding. The typical executive might have gone from thinking "staff up at all costs!!" to "AI will mean fewer devs doing higher v…

There is danger of losing the apprenticeship nature of our industry, where companies who take on grads help the industry as a whole.

How this plays out is a good question. You need a way for people new to the industry to get real world experience, and express their talents.

This might just fix itself. After all if company A has AI, and so does B, then AI is table stakes, and people are still needed for the edge, whatever that might be, at least while people are still the customers :-). An example of where people are not the customers: stock market. Mostly bots and algorithms buying that stuff.

Re: Has anyone here had their jobs affected by AI in a negative way yet?

#14

Post by dormento »

quickthrower2 wrote: post #11
RollAHardSix wrote: post #10

Personally, I am terrified. I am doing GRC (Governance, Risk Management, Compliance) for a Marketing and PR Firm that is really just a digital marketing firm-- and we have already been told from industry insiders we can't bill over 70 dollars an hour for writers and expect to get the contract. I think AI has a very strong possibility of completely wrecking this industry and will allow either major marketing firms or…

It will wreck it from both sides: marketer get paid less, and the new marketing word soup will be drivel. If your marketing can be done by AI that isn't AGI then it will just suck. Subtly suck. Sort of a uncanny hill (looks good to the boss, but silently bores the audiences). Might be good for SEO though, to get some cost effective pseudo-advertising via. Google organic search.

I call it the "good enough" problem. When you really thing about it, the quality requirements from most art/programming/writing jobs are really not that strict. With new AI techniques, I envision that the bottom of the pyramid will be eaten, but at the top, the input of human creators will be valued even more.

Re: Has anyone here had their jobs affected by AI in a negative way yet?

#15

Post by oriel »

ironlake wrote: post #2

I'm a software engineer and I also write fiction. (90+% of my income for SE, as you might guess). For the fiction, editors are getting flooded with submissions written or assisted by LLMs, so the competition has increased and editors have less time to evaluate submissions. It's all the way up and down the chain: online magazines, small press, agents, big publishers. Not life-changing for me. I think it has been for s…

> because the lead manager is now a prompt-engineer

This is actually one of my bigger short-term concerns, where someone who doesnt have any real understanding or good intuition is given the illusion of competence, while only creating more problems and work for those who have actual competence.

Referencing the four stages of competence[1], this set of persons being Unconsciously Incompetent, are more likely to cause far more harm than good in the medium term, in the name of efficiency or such.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_stages_of_competence

Re: Has anyone here had their jobs affected by AI in a negative way yet?

#16

Post by marto1 »

quickthrower2 wrote: post #12
softwaredoug wrote: post #3

In the context of layoffs, I feel like junior software engineers have been indirectly impacted by AI. There's seemingly a lot of demand for senior talent and much less for junior talent. I imagine at least some of this would be caused by real or imagined productivity gains from AI tools for coding. The typical executive might have gone from thinking "staff up at all costs!!" to "AI will mean fewer devs doing higher v…

There is danger of losing the apprenticeship nature of our industry, where companies who take on grads help the industry as a whole. How this plays out is a good question. You need a way for people new to the industry to get real world experience, and express their talents. This might just fix itself. After all if company A has AI, and so does B, then AI is table stakes, and people are still needed for the edge, what…

> How this plays out is a good question.

Look into what happened to Japanese wood printers around the time of the industrial revolution over there. It was a many layer apprenticeship system where everyone had a separate job - the bottom layer, mostly children, would make prints for candy wrappers and such until you get to the top - the masters which dealt with the most valuable and skilled work.

The lowest layers got cut, replaced by machines, and the entire structure eventually toppled. Including the work that couldn't be done by a machine - it was simply not requested anymore or there wasn't enough people coming from below to fill the ranks.

It's somewhat doubtful whether software engineers will feel the same both, because of the actual impact AI and that the job itself IS automation by nature. There could be political factors, however, that could skew things otherwise.

Re: Has anyone here had their jobs affected by AI in a negative way yet?

#17

Post by ian0 »

AlexITC wrote: post #8

Let me share a story about this from one of our customers. My customer asked me about writing a smart contract but we did not had the capacity to handle it. A few days after that, my customer gets back to me sharing a basic smart contract he managed to create using ChatGPT, since them, my customer has kept iterating over this, it took him a few weeks to get the functionality he wanted. My customer explained to me tha…

Recently I was writing a small, simple contract and they lawyer I usually ask to draft was busy. I generated it using chatGPT in around and then forwarded it to the lawyer to review. Came back with only minor addition.

The prompting took around 3 mins, was in english and the outputted contract was in Indonesian by request. Not a replacement for a lawyer, but it does a great job at boilerplate.

Post reply on HN