Live data from Hacker News

Was there a U.S. nuclear weapons accident at a Dutch air base?

fas.org

11–20 of 96 posts

Re: Was there a U.S. nuclear weapons accident at a Dutch air base?

#12

I remember hearing about bad OPSEC at Volkel. Something about how there was sensitive national security secrets indirectly being leaked bc soldiers didn’t set their Quizlet flashcards to private when studying for their exams.

Wow, I missed that one. I just looked it up.

https://www.bellingcat.com/news/2021/05/28/us-soldiers-expos...

I know these human mistakes are inevitable in a large organization, but it's still sobering seeing that a soldier would post nuclear vault release code locations and more online. I guess it's easy to be careless in the daily grind whether it's PII or nuclear secrets...

Re: Was there a U.S. nuclear weapons accident at a Dutch air base?

#13

It must be emphasized up front that there is no official confirmation that the image was taken at Volkel Air Base, that the bent B61 shape is a real weapon (versus a trainer), or that the damage was the result of an accident (versus a training simulation).

Exactly. Quite the chain of speculation built from a single image.

It's just that Finland joined NATO...

Re: Was there a U.S. nuclear weapons accident at a Dutch air base?

#15

It must be emphasized up front that there is no official confirmation that the image was taken at Volkel Air Base, that the bent B61 shape is a real weapon (versus a trainer), or that the damage was the result of an accident (versus a training simulation).

Exactly. Quite the chain of speculation built from a single image.

To be fair, it is the news media… Reporters take nuggets of information, plus buckets of speculation, and spin it into something that you will click on.

Re: Was there a U.S. nuclear weapons accident at a Dutch air base?

#17

I remember hearing about bad OPSEC at Volkel. Something about how there was sensitive national security secrets indirectly being leaked bc soldiers didn’t set their Quizlet flashcards to private when studying for their exams.

If someone puts classified information into Quizlet, that constitutes spillage whether they set it to private or not.

Sometimes this kind of thing needs to be explained even to very senior people, not just lowly troops. I knew of a four-star general asking a few years ago why we didn't use Signal for stuff instead of Teams (O365 tenant hosted in Microsoft's Government Community Cloud), because he "heard that it's so secure that even the NSA can't break it." The answer is that there's a difference between a system being "secure" and being accredited for classified information or even unclassified information that the government owns.

Edited to add: Another very senior DoD person actually got in trouble for using Signal for official business a couple years ago because, among other reasons, there's no way for the government comply with FOIA when someone is using a personal account on a commercial application like that.

Re: Was there a U.S. nuclear weapons accident at a Dutch air base?

#18

I remember hearing about bad OPSEC at Volkel. Something about how there was sensitive national security secrets indirectly being leaked bc soldiers didn’t set their Quizlet flashcards to private when studying for their exams.

uhm, setting the quizlet flashcards to private would have still resulted in a leak of sensitive data...

Re: Was there a U.S. nuclear weapons accident at a Dutch air base?

#19

When the headline is asking the audience, the answer is usually no.

Article: “It must be emphasized up front that there is no official confirmation that the image was taken at Volkel Air Base, that the bent B61 shape is a real weapon (versus a trainer), or that the damage was the result of an accident (versus a training simulation).”

Headline writer/editor: “Hold my beer”

Post reply on HN