Live data from Hacker News

The American Diet Has a Sandwich Problem

wsj.com

11–20 of 129 posts

Re: The American Diet Has a Sandwich Problem

#11
> Sandwiches are the number one source of sodium and saturated fat in Americans’ diets, making up about one-fifth of our daily sodium intake and 19% of our daily saturated fat calories

20% of sodium and saturated fat calories for a single meal doesn't really sound very alarming.

Re: The American Diet Has a Sandwich Problem

#12
post #7

> Since a soggy PB&J is unappealing, Dr. Roberto says it’s pretty easy to rein in the amount of sweet jam. “There’s a built-in mechanism against overjellying,” she says. “It’s a really nice type of sandwich.” The trick is to put peanut butter on both pieces of bread so it can't absorb the jam. Then you can put as much as you like :-).

Hard disagree. Soggy PB&J is excellent. Soggy PB and honey is even better.

Re: The American Diet Has a Sandwich Problem

#15

Nothing tortillas can't fix.

Can't tell if this is sarcastic. Hispanic communities suffer from large amounts of obesity, some due to genetic issues, but diet is an overwhelming factor. A proper tortilla has three ingredients: flour, lard and salt. Not exactly a staple in a slimming diet.

Re: The American Diet Has a Sandwich Problem

#16
This article references salt consumption multiple times. I thought that was a myth of the past. Salt consumption has almost zero to do with blood pressure. IIRC, it's primarily based on eating more calories than one burns.

As always, eat less, move more.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/its-time-to-end-t...

Re: The American Diet Has a Sandwich Problem

#17
post #9

When I roast a chicken I save the breast for sandwiches, but there's a reason people don't make their sandwiches that way: processed meats are much cheaper. You might as well write an article that the American sandwich has a cost problem. Face it: the sandwich is a luxury food. Healthier things are often cheaper, too. The vegetable street taco at my nearest taco truck is almost a complete diet by itself, and it's the…

Aside from being cheaper I like the texture of processed chicken more, they are usually easier to eat and have herbs and spices infused in them. I try to avoid bacon, ham, beef and sausages and hopefully that's good enough!

Re: The American Diet Has a Sandwich Problem

#18

> Sandwiches are the number one source of sodium and saturated fat in Americans’ diets, making up about one-fifth of our daily sodium intake and 19% of our daily saturated fat calories 20% of sodium and saturated fat calories for a single meal doesn't really sound very alarming.

Yeah, how many meals do people eat in a day anyways? Like max 5?

Re: The American Diet Has a Sandwich Problem

#19
> Sandwiches have grown less healthy in the past 40 years, Dr. Mozaffarian says. Culprits include highly processed grains in bread and the low-fat push that took off in the 1980s, which nutritionists now say led to the consumption of more deli meats marketed as low-fat.

Low-fat wasn't just a "push". Medical experts effectively lobbied the government to introduce dietary mandates at very high levels (like nutrition percentages) and on low levels (school lunches). The end result was carbs, carbs, carbs, cheap carbs.

The glycemic index is probably one of the most underrated aspects for diet. It boggles my mind that the doctor at the end recommended a PB&J. Sure - in a complete vacuum it has fewer calories. But you are going to end up way hungrier and crankier calorie-for-calorie.

Re: The American Diet Has a Sandwich Problem

#20
> Each serving a day of processed meat is associated with a 42% increased risk of heart disease and a 19% increased risk of diabetes

The wording of this either is confusing or is a huge understatement. Does this mean that eating a serving a day for some time period correlates with a huge increase in heart disease and diabetes or, read literally, that each day you eat a serving of processed meat correlates to a huge increased risk (which would further increase across more days)?

Post reply on HN