Live data from Hacker News

AI’s Instagram Problem

deeplearning.ai

11–20 of 99 posts

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#12
Idk about AI having an Instagram problem, but I know Instagram has an AI problem. So many fake accounts with AI as actors and they send you chat messages trying to pretend to be real people. They even react to comments and can discern good from bad comments.

At first it was interesting. Now it's just annoying.

Then the Instagram algorithm, if you comment on coffee ads that you drink tea, you'll get tea ads. It will show you progressively naked women, cameltoes and similar softcore erotica. Sometimes even real porn. When you report that porn accounts your report will not even be reviewed and denied. But God beware you post the word tits. Instant harassment automoderation. All the women that follow you instantly message you saying hi, how are you, how old are you, what is your name, where are you from etc. I think they're infobots trying to build profiles and sell your data.

Some play the old " I'm a hot girl but can't post my picture, please buy me an iTunes gift card ", like I was born yesterday. And how dumb their game is. They see you commenting on a picture you liked, take that picture, claim to be that person, only on a private account, and they picked you, their loyal fan. Many of them are cheap porn actresses or accounts of people having built profiles from the pictures those porn actresses post, only modified by AI.

I am so tired of that platform. And then they serve you small 1 minute clips of stand up comedy, cats or dogs, or some stupid 1 person having a chat with themself. Let's not forget those "how do I say it at my workplace" "expert" vids. And lots of ads in between.

Instagram is so disgusting.

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#13

All AI projects are valuable, but it's annoying and demotivating to work hard on a unique and useful project and have no one read/use it because it doesn't stand out in the extremely rapidly-evolving ecosystem. Most of my AI text-generation and image-generation projects and tools have already become obsolete by technology released in the past few months, and I've almost given up competing.

When asked how to keep up with all of this AI/ML stuff when starting your own AI business, Jeremy Howard (general genius and co-creator of fast.ai) replied that you don't need to know everything and keep up with everything. Pick a niche and focus just on that. And if that keeps changing too fast or is too much, pick a niche inside that niche.

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#14
This is correct, but there's also some meta comment to be made that research has an "instragram problem". What he's talking about isn't really even AI so much as deep learning: there are lots of other branches that now get virtually no play relative to deep learning. And then there are all sorts of adjacent CS, image processing (when was the last time you saw someone talk about wavelets), language analysis, and other research avenues, probably often better suited to many problems, that get buried under the hype.

This is why academic research is so important. All the corporate money is flowing to deep learning, grant agencies should be sustaining the other more fundamental areas.

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#15
post #12

Idk about AI having an Instagram problem, but I know Instagram has an AI problem. So many fake accounts with AI as actors and they send you chat messages trying to pretend to be real people. They even react to comments and can discern good from bad comments. At first it was interesting. Now it's just annoying. Then the Instagram algorithm, if you comment on coffee ads that you drink tea, you'll get tea ads. It will s…

> Instagram is so disgusting.

Why are you still using it? (Not trying to troll you, I'm legitimately curious -- it really doesn't sound like it's offering you anything positive at this point)

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#16
post #8
post #3

> AI develops so quickly that waves of new ideas keep coming: quantum AI, self-supervised learning, transformers, diffusion models, large language models, and on and on. I wonder what’s wrong with us as a species. We love to run into one direction all together chasing the next big thing just until the next big trend comes along. Quantum AI crypto LLMs for the win!

That's definitely not "us as a species". I would say this is a specific effect of post-industrial, market-driven economy - and even there, probably restricted to specific communities such as entrepreneurs. By and large, I believe, people are conservative and would prefer for things to stay as they were, unless the change solves a specific problem. Sometimes people actively tried to resist "progress" and had to be for…

And I would say its even more detailed than that.

In general your most staunch conservative doesn't mind things changing if it personally benefits them greatly (especially if they don't bear most the burden of its effects).

Your most avid progressive commonly want the things that bring them comfort to stay the same, even if its potentially harmful to someone else.

I believe the issue here is we're playing "everything everywhere all at once". Everywhere on the globe is pretty much instantly connected to everything else via digital communications. There is no more sit by the sidelines zone that gets to avoid this connectivity. You may not want it, but you have to stop everyone else from bringing that connectivity too, and somehow maintain casual connectivity economically unless you want to play caveman.

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#17
post #12

Idk about AI having an Instagram problem, but I know Instagram has an AI problem. So many fake accounts with AI as actors and they send you chat messages trying to pretend to be real people. They even react to comments and can discern good from bad comments. At first it was interesting. Now it's just annoying. Then the Instagram algorithm, if you comment on coffee ads that you drink tea, you'll get tea ads. It will s…

> Instagram is so disgusting. Why are you still using it? (Not trying to troll you, I'm legitimately curious -- it really doesn't sound like it's offering you anything positive at this point)

As someone using Instagram but has a Todo list item to close my FB/Instagram/Meta account, the reason I still use it (and only Instagram) is to follow artists. A hyper curated list of individuals that post interesting things that I can check up on. It's what I lost when I shuttered my Twitter account. I use it as a glorified RSS feed rather than as a way to interact socially.

But yeah, the bad outweighs the good, and other than spending the time to archive data, I do plan to shut it down.

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#18

Stuff does happen though. - Facebook enters the geolocation game (dowalla/foursquare/instagram) - Google releases reviews to maps (yelp & co) - Amazon starts it's own airline (Fedex) - Microsoft adds ChatGPT to search (Kagi, Duckduckgo, etc..) Sometimes it's hard to recover your startup when a big player does something to fill the void you were targeting.

How does DDG and Kagi competes with ChatGpt ? In my understanding their “responses” above search results works like Google graph, but I’ll be happy to be corrected.

Most people don't use search engines to search, they use them to answer.

That's why Google, DDG, Kagi and others are all putting summary blurbs.

Now that we have ChatGPT a lot of people are going to cut out searches in exchange for prompts.

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#19

All AI projects are valuable, but it's annoying and demotivating to work hard on a unique and useful project and have no one read/use it because it doesn't stand out in the extremely rapidly-evolving ecosystem. Most of my AI text-generation and image-generation projects and tools have already become obsolete by technology released in the past few months, and I've almost given up competing.

One advise I'll never forget (from an interview with late mathematician Maryam Mirzakhani) is that you don't have to race faster than everyone else (although if you can, that's great!). You can just run in a direction no one is running toward (and hopefully be persistent). Then you're only racing yourself and speed is largely irrelevant.

I myself know I'm very slow, specially developing projects. So I don't try to race anyone, except contribute to things I know are neglected. There are so many neglected problems, you don't need to work on the most coveted fields.

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#20

This is correct, but there's also some meta comment to be made that research has an "instragram problem". What he's talking about isn't really even AI so much as deep learning: there are lots of other branches that now get virtually no play relative to deep learning. And then there are all sorts of adjacent CS, image processing (when was the last time you saw someone talk about wavelets), language analysis, and other…

Academic research has the same problem. When I studied neuroscience, flashy fMRI studies received substantially more funding than fundamental research. Without understanding how small neural nets work, it's difficult to construct bottom-up theories of the brain.
Post reply on HN