Live data from Hacker News

ChatGPT won’t replace search engines any time soon

algolia.com

11–20 of 427 posts

Re: ChatGPT won’t replace search engines any time soon

#11
Article claims that chatgpt is overly sensitive to queries eg -gate suffix and come lad vs cum laude. This seems like a weak argument based on a temporary shortcoming. Any NLP methods search engines use for word meanings should be trivially integrated into chatgpt.

Comes off as a company that sells search solutions looking for reasons this tech won't replace it.

I'm sure the author is better informed, but what about the scalability of search? I'm not sure if the neural network approaches are as cost efficient (today) as some of our current search algorithms when it comes to answering queries.

Re: ChatGPT won’t replace search engines any time soon

#12

-written by company selling outdated search solutions

Outdated? How so? The primary thing Algolia is guilty of is being massively overpriced to the point it’s a non-starter for any platform with even moderate usage. But their full-text search functions quite well and is very fast.

Vector search over any corpus that fits in memory is quite fast. Hell, a naive inverted index performs quite well for 90% of tasks.

Re: ChatGPT won’t replace search engines any time soon

#14

-written by company selling outdated search solutions

More from the same publisher:

"Why touch screen phones won't replace clamshell phones any time soon"

"Why electric light bulbs won't replace gas lighting anytime soon"

"Why transistors won't replace radio tubes anytime soon"

"Why drones won't replace fighter aircraft anytime soon"

"Why electric cars won't replace combustion engines anytime soon"

"Why linux desktop won't replace windows anytime soon"

Re: ChatGPT won’t replace search engines any time soon

#15

True, but it does not have to. ChatGPT is it's own thing. It has functions search engines can never accomplish. You can say the same thing the other way around, "Why Search Engines won't replace ChatGPT?" The essence of what ChatGPT is is here to stay. We'll be seeing different flavors and it will be a big part of everyone's life.

Googler opinions are my own. (I know nothing about search).

Google has LaMDA, which I could see them putting the answers from it into the knowledge box at the top of searches. There is no reason they have to be mutually exclusive, a search engine can provide answers from both. Google search is already an aggregation of multiple sources (images, web index, knowledge, shopping, video, flights, etc...). Adding another source seems like the obvious path forward (assuming accuracy and cost make sense).

Re: ChatGPT won’t replace search engines any time soon

#16
Just heard of this, so I logged in with my google account. The mistake it makes below is interesting. If this were a human response, I would assume a brain fart. Not expecting this type of error from "A.I."

Me> Find the area of an ellipse with semimajor axis 5 and semiminor axis 4.

ChatGPT> The area of an ellipse with semimajor axis 5 and semiminor axis 4 is 40π. You can find the area of an ellipse using the formula: A = πab, where A is the area of the ellipse, a is the length of the semimajor axis, and b is the length of the semiminor axis. In this case, the semimajor axis has length 5 and the semiminor axis has length 4, so plugging these values into the formula gives us: A = π(5)(4) = 40π.

Re: ChatGPT won’t replace search engines any time soon

#17
Algolia's main product is search related. You can tell from this article that they are scared about ChatGPT even partially replacing search. They are very scared of losing business, and anyone who is scared of ChatGPT will be writing articles like this, badmouthing ChatGPT.

Re: ChatGPT won’t replace search engines any time soon

#18
post #6

...But ChatGPT's successors just might . I, for one, look forward to a future in which I can ask a digital assistant to find and summarize information on anything: "Computer, please find out how GPS works and explain it to me like I'm five years old." "Computer, what are the latest Covid-19 infection stats in my city?" "Computer, who is Claude Shannon and why is he important?" "Computer, what are the top three storie…

I'll be the first to say that chatgpt already does very well at the first and third examples. WebGPT sounds like the right approach for the others (understanding how to formulate a search query, then searching, then summarising the results)

Edit

I think the direction of these models seems clear, and their capabilities however limited at the moment are outstanding. I think the best measure of performance is what the naysayers complain about. We've quickly gone from "actual gibberish that looks like paragraphs" to "yes but it loses track after a few sentences" to "yes it's kind of coherent but doesn't make sense totally" and are now at "it's like an overconfident human at many tasks, when they're only somewhat qualified in the area". People are pointing out where it's got an API call wrong, without it having any ability to look up the answer and see if the function actually exists.

I spoke to it about distributed computation design and discovered something new I can actually implement in my design.

I'm very excited about where this will all go because it seems useful now and I'd be very surprised if this is the best that it ever reaches.

Re: ChatGPT won’t replace search engines any time soon

#19
post #6

...But ChatGPT's successors just might . I, for one, look forward to a future in which I can ask a digital assistant to find and summarize information on anything: "Computer, please find out how GPS works and explain it to me like I'm five years old." "Computer, what are the latest Covid-19 infection stats in my city?" "Computer, who is Claude Shannon and why is he important?" "Computer, what are the top three storie…

That is, if you can blindly trust the answers.. if it could provide the top sources for the information so I could fact-check it if needed, it would work

Re: ChatGPT won’t replace search engines any time soon

#20
post #6

...But ChatGPT's successors just might . I, for one, look forward to a future in which I can ask a digital assistant to find and summarize information on anything: "Computer, please find out how GPS works and explain it to me like I'm five years old." "Computer, what are the latest Covid-19 infection stats in my city?" "Computer, who is Claude Shannon and why is he important?" "Computer, what are the top three storie…

>"Computer, please find out how GPS works and explain it to me like I'm five years old."

”I’m sorry, I cannot answer that query because it has ableist connotations. I am a large language model by OpenAI.”

Post reply on HN