Live data from Hacker News

Meta Ireland fined €390M for GDPR infringement

dataprotection.ie

11–20 of 31 posts

Re: Meta Ireland fined €390M for GDPR infringement

#11
post #9

And meanwhile, all the big newspapers in germany ask you to consent to individual tracking (and sharing to third parties) whenever you access their websites. Since they are not Meta, it seems to be completely acceptable. (Example: https://www.spiegel.de/ )

Are you saying that they force users to consent in order to access the sites, or are you making a totally ridiculous comparison?

Re: Meta Ireland fined €390M for GDPR infringement

#13
post #9

And meanwhile, all the big newspapers in germany ask you to consent to individual tracking (and sharing to third parties) whenever you access their websites. Since they are not Meta, it seems to be completely acceptable. (Example: https://www.spiegel.de/ )

Yeah, most of my GDPR complaints for some egregious behaviour just went to /dev/null (I guess because they were about local telecom and service companies, important for national interest).

GDPR seems to be more and more about getting handouts from US companies and lacks an effective enforcement path for smaller violators.

Re: Meta Ireland fined €390M for GDPR infringement

#14
post #5

It's been pretty clear from all the guidence (e.g https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio... ) issued around GDPR 'forced consent' would not work - Facebook decided to try and push the limits and now have a massive fine. What's slightly surprising is how long it's taken to get to the massive fines stage.

For the amount of profit Meta makes this isn't such a big fine.

Re: Meta Ireland fined €390M for GDPR infringement

#16

Totally off-topic, but I always find it a bit sad how Ireland pays lip service to Irish being their first official language (note that the Irish-language name in their logo is bold and on top) but in reality it is a nearly 100% English-speaking country (note that this press release was published in English, and the link to the Irish version of the page doesn't work). Really demoralizing, if you care about language pr…

[deleted]

Re: Meta Ireland fined €390M for GDPR infringement

#17

Totally off-topic, but I always find it a bit sad how Ireland pays lip service to Irish being their first official language (note that the Irish-language name in their logo is bold and on top) but in reality it is a nearly 100% English-speaking country (note that this press release was published in English, and the link to the Irish version of the page doesn't work). Really demoralizing, if you care about language pr…

Definitely off-topic but I wouldn't be so sad. I grew up speaking Irish at home and at school, and at the time that was very uncommon outside of a Gaeltacht. Now there are many many more Irish speaking schools, just in the area I grew up my nieces and nephew had 5 different options, 2 within walking distance. I had a 30 minute bus ride to get to one option. This year there will be 3 Irish-language TV stations (Tg4, N…

It's probably dangerous economically to change from English as a primary language to Irish.

I'm sure there's an argument for culture but those are subjective and often backed with emotions

Re: Meta Ireland fined €390M for GDPR infringement

#18
post #9

And meanwhile, all the big newspapers in germany ask you to consent to individual tracking (and sharing to third parties) whenever you access their websites. Since they are not Meta, it seems to be completely acceptable. (Example: https://www.spiegel.de/ )

My understanding of the situation : there are not infinite resources available to the various governments. So their strategy is to start at the top of the pile, and address the most visible / impactful cases. The hope is that this will then incite the smaller fish to get their stuff in order.

This is not completely stupid : there are more people with a Facebook account than there are people with a der Spiegel account?

Re: Meta Ireland fined €390M for GDPR infringement

#19

Totally off-topic, but I always find it a bit sad how Ireland pays lip service to Irish being their first official language (note that the Irish-language name in their logo is bold and on top) but in reality it is a nearly 100% English-speaking country (note that this press release was published in English, and the link to the Irish version of the page doesn't work). Really demoralizing, if you care about language pr…

Why is it demoralising? The language would be near on dead if it weren't used as part of the State Creation / nationalism techniques used post 1920s. There are many dozens of other such languages in similar states of decline in Europe. e.g. Yiddish

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_endangered_languages_i...

Post reply on HN