Live data from Hacker News

Musk wants to do a “total rewrite” of Twitter

thedailybeast.com

11–20 of 24 posts

Re: Musk wants to do a “total rewrite” of Twitter

#11
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right, but the whole reason he gave to do a whole rewrite was that Twitter’s tech stack was horrible… but then couldn’t even answer what is that tech stack and what makes it so horrible

Yeah, you guys are sooooo much smarter than Elon. Carryon.

[dead]

Re: Musk wants to do a “total rewrite” of Twitter

#12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right, but the whole reason he gave to do a whole rewrite was that Twitter’s tech stack was horrible… but then couldn’t even answer what is that tech stack and what makes it so horrible

Yeah, you guys are sooooo much smarter than Elon. Carryon.

Smarter? Maybe, maybe not. Able to articulate a basic reason to rewrite or not? Most of us here probably are, yet Musk chose the least compelling route, ad hominem attacks.

Re: Musk wants to do a “total rewrite” of Twitter

#13

Musk: "I think we won't get to the refactor if we don't make these changes" "why?" Musk: "because we're going to be bankrupt" "what's the runway?" Musk: *silence* "Elon you're you're our philosopher um you know Plato would be very proud of you. You're extremely technically competent and I think really understand how to how to drive things in a in a good direction. You know I I really love how you're also leaning into…

That last bit, it’s very hard to believe it was _serious_.

Re: Musk wants to do a “total rewrite” of Twitter

#14
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right, but the whole reason he gave to do a whole rewrite was that Twitter’s tech stack was horrible… but then couldn’t even answer what is that tech stack and what makes it so horrible

Yeah, you guys are sooooo much smarter than Elon. Carryon.

I mean, yes, I would assume a lot of people here are smarter than Elon Musk, and certainly far more familiar with software engineering.

Re: Musk wants to do a “total rewrite” of Twitter

#15

Musk: "I think we won't get to the refactor if we don't make these changes" "why?" Musk: "because we're going to be bankrupt" "what's the runway?" Musk: *silence* "Elon you're you're our philosopher um you know Plato would be very proud of you. You're extremely technically competent and I think really understand how to how to drive things in a in a good direction. You know I I really love how you're also leaning into…

That last bit, it’s very hard to believe it was _serious_.

Mr. Musk, your campaign seems to have the momentum of a runaway freight train. Why are you so popular ?

Ooh, a tough question, but a fair one.

Re: Musk wants to do a “total rewrite” of Twitter

#16

Aka "the single worst strategic mistake that any software company can make": https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/06/things-you-should-...

It's my first instinct when I look at someone else's code. Or even my code I wrote yesterday.

This is why experienced engineers don't just act out on first instinct.

Re: Musk wants to do a “total rewrite” of Twitter

#17

Lol. Wasn’t built here huh? Has he ever worked with legacy software ever before? It’s possible he has not. Wild. Do it! And GPL the stack you leave for dead please, Elon.

He paid $44 billion not so start from scratch, and now he wants to start from scratch.

Re: Musk wants to do a “total rewrite” of Twitter

#18

Musk: "I think we won't get to the refactor if we don't make these changes" "why?" Musk: "because we're going to be bankrupt" "what's the runway?" Musk: *silence* "Elon you're you're our philosopher um you know Plato would be very proud of you. You're extremely technically competent and I think really understand how to how to drive things in a in a good direction. You know I I really love how you're also leaning into…

That last bit, it’s very hard to believe it was _serious_.

I don't think the person who said it was serious, but I think they understood that Musk needed to hear it.

Re: Musk wants to do a “total rewrite” of Twitter

#19

Lol. Wasn’t built here huh? Has he ever worked with legacy software ever before? It’s possible he has not. Wild. Do it! And GPL the stack you leave for dead please, Elon.

He paid $44 billion not so start from scratch, and now he wants to start from scratch.

Not that this isn't dumb, but what he paid for was the customer base and the domain name, not the software. The software is cheap; acquiring the customers is not.

Rewriting software from scratch isn't cheap, either, especially if you're doing it at the same time as trying to keep the existing code base running. It's practically never a good idea.

But even if it were worth rewriting the software, it's still not what he paid for. He paid $44B because the software is so famous that we're talking about it here, and that would last even through a rewrite. (Assuming the rewrite was done correctly, which it usually isn't.)

Post reply on HN