Live data from Hacker News

Personal newsletters as a calmer alternative to social networks

philipithomas.com

11–20 of 75 posts

Re: Personal newsletters as a calmer alternative to social networks

#12

I hate newsletters. I don't want them in my inbox. I want them in my RSS feed where they belong. Thankfully substack has feeds.

A good platform should support both email and RSS, and give users the choice.

(Postcard, which I discuss in the submitted post, does support both.)

Re: Personal newsletters as a calmer alternative to social networks

#13

I hate newsletters. I don't want them in my inbox. I want them in my RSS feed where they belong. Thankfully substack has feeds.

A good platform should support both email and RSS, and give users the choice. (Postcard, which I discuss in the submitted post, does support both.)

Yep! You can think of email as a version of RSS that regular people actually know how to use ;)

Re: Personal newsletters as a calmer alternative to social networks

#15
Kind of a shameless plug for my newsletter, and also a nod in agreement. I love being able to share articles that I find interesting, share useful tidbits and stuff, and getting responses from folks who actually read it and want to talk more. I love the concept and hope more people do it!

Mine is here: https://cassidoo.co/newsletter

Re: Personal newsletters as a calmer alternative to social networks

#16
post #6

This is what I liked about the open blogosphere of 2000 to 2008. Whereas something like Twitter is optimized for the fast-take and the brutal one-liner, blogs allowed actual conversations. You could write something serious, develop the idea, and maybe some other people would engage with it, also at a serious level. But then the walled-gardens began to gain ground (Facebook, Twitter, and then later Instagram) and the…

Before 2000, there were the "shared spaces" of mailing lists. I think of Winer the same way you probably think of Zuck.

Re: Personal newsletters as a calmer alternative to social networks

#20
This looks really nice. I've been fiddling around building newsletter-adjacent products for a few years, and I've been wanting a simple Substack-alternative* that's good for casual use so that I can recommend it to users.

Can I make one request? Please provide single opt-in as an option! v2 invisible Recaptcha is effective for stopping bots, and most of the time people won't even be shown a challenge. Double opt-in confirmation emails only have about a 70% conversion rate in my experience (and that's counting only people who get past Recaptcha), so you lose a big chunk of subscribers. I almost started using Ghost a while ago for my own newsletter, but no single opt-in is just a deal breaker for me.

See also https://mailchimp.com/resources/why-single-opt-in-and-an-upd...

*Substack _is_ good for casual use, but I have various beefs with them, the main one being that they're trying to build yet another platform instead of being part of an ecosystem.

Post reply on HN