Live data from Hacker News

Who invented the thumb drive?

spectrum.ieee.org

11–20 of 190 posts

Re: Who invented the thumb drive?

#11
post #4

The biggest deal for these taking off was that they just worked on Windows without any special drivers or messing around. It made them appear magic. People lost their minds over how much easier and better they were than all the other stuff - burning CD's, floppy drives, zip disks, LS120 etc. You couldn't email large files and WeTransfer didn't exist. We couldn't get them in fast enough for the users where I worked at…

Obligatory xkcd: https://xkcd.com/949/

Re: Who invented the thumb drive?

#12

> global sales of thumb drives from all manufacturers surpassed $7 billion, a number that is expected to rise to more than $10 billion by 2028. More than 20 years later, they are indeed dirty cheap. However, I often find them to be unreliable with slow/unsteady real speeds. Meanwhile, small NVMe-based devices in either this thumb-format or SD-format (5 years in the making [1]) are still not very popular, so the price…

There is more than a 10x price difference between slow run-of-the-mill sd cards and the high speed cards a photographer might go for. Why would it be any different for thumb drives? Higher speeds are more difficult to achieve and make up a small fraction of the total demand. And to make it worse people who need speed tend to be less price sensitive.

Re: Who invented the thumb drive?

#13
It should also be noted that one of the reasons thumb drives took off when they did was not just due to USB.. as technically USB has been around for a few years and there were things like CF card readers coming on the market, and other flash storage readers a few years earlier.. so why did it take until later? Because Win 95 and Win 98 did not have plug and play drivers for USB mass storage devices, at all. I think it wasn't until Win98SE (edit: for true generic controllers it may have been Win2K even?) that there was a USB driver for generic thumb drives. But theoretically the tech was around and could have been implemented as early as 1996.

Re: Who invented the thumb drive?

#14

I can tell I'm getting older by the number of articles I read that take time to describe 'history' of things that seem obvious since I lived through them, like the explanation of how 3.5" high density 'Floppy disks' held up to 1.44MB. Like... "I know... oh god some people don't know that."

I mean to add, the article says that thumb drives are still hot and the market will grow by billions a year more in a few years, but... I haven't used a thumb drive in years. The only time I actually went to look for one was to plug it into a shitty digital picture frame, and that one would also accept SD cards.

Re: Who invented the thumb drive?

#15
Netac still holds patent globally until 2019. Other manufacturers paid Netac more than 2 billions over these years.

Made in China has changed a lot of things. It doesn't matter who really invented thumb drives. I think the first mass production/sale of thumb drives happened in China. That's the reason the patent was granted to Netac.

Re: Who invented the thumb drive?

#16
I am the proud owner of an 8MB IBM branded DiskOnKey flash drive. Plugging it into my linux system, it throws a lot of errors, but I do have a ext2 filesystem on it. I can mount it and find the little 'hello world' text file I put in there last June :)

Re: Who invented the thumb drive?

#17
post #10

I guess this was one of those "inventions" which are pretty obvious in hindsight, and I bet more than one party had already though of building a USB drive, it was just a question of the USB interface becoming widespread enough and of flash memory becoming affordable and reliable enough. Actually, flash memory cards with proprietary interfaces were available for some time before the year 2000 given in the article (Com…

That reminds me, I don't remember if it was USB 1 or 2, but at some point I added a card to my PC that added two USB ports. I think that must've been USB 2.0 because the sockets were blue and I'm fairly sure I could hook up my keyboard and mouse through USB already.

Re: Who invented the thumb drive?

#18
post #4

The biggest deal for these taking off was that they just worked on Windows without any special drivers or messing around. It made them appear magic. People lost their minds over how much easier and better they were than all the other stuff - burning CD's, floppy drives, zip disks, LS120 etc. You couldn't email large files and WeTransfer didn't exist. We couldn't get them in fast enough for the users where I worked at…

To be fair, floppies were pretty easy, just had no capacity.

Re: Who invented the thumb drive?

#19

I can tell I'm getting older by the number of articles I read that take time to describe 'history' of things that seem obvious since I lived through them, like the explanation of how 3.5" high density 'Floppy disks' held up to 1.44MB. Like... "I know... oh god some people don't know that."

I mean to add, the article says that thumb drives are still hot and the market will grow by billions a year more in a few years, but... I haven't used a thumb drive in years. The only time I actually went to look for one was to plug it into a shitty digital picture frame, and that one would also accept SD cards.

I still use the higher end ones (which have a USB SATA controller and a bona fide SSD) to carry photos and big files around when I'm on vacation. They look like bulky, yet ordinary USB flash drives.

Re: Who invented the thumb drive?

#20

It should also be noted that one of the reasons thumb drives took off when they did was not just due to USB.. as technically USB has been around for a few years and there were things like CF card readers coming on the market, and other flash storage readers a few years earlier.. so why did it take until later? Because Win 95 and Win 98 did not have plug and play drivers for USB mass storage devices, at all. I think i…

>But theoretically the tech was around and could have been implemented as early as 1996.

The USB physical form-factor and electrical signals were 1996 but the protocol for storage devices appears to be later in 1998:

Universal Serial Bus Mass Storage Class Specification Overview V1.0 Revision October 22, 1998 : https://cscott.net/usb_dev/data/devclass/usbmassover_10.pdf

Post reply on HN