Live data from Hacker News

SOPA: The End of the Internet as We Know it

bostinno.com

11–12 of 12 posts

Re: SOPA: The End of the Internet as We Know it

#11

Okay I'm not going to attempt to support/defend SOPA but I have some serious questions: Why do all of these SOPA articles on HN fail to mention that this bill specifically targets "foreign" sites? They all mention a possible threat against youtube, facebook etc, but since these are "domestic" sites aren't they excluded? Is there a particular definition or qualification in the bill that I missed that would widen the s…

Perhaps I shouldn't have said that I won't attempt to defend SOPA. I am obviously defending certain parts of it. However, I still don't support it, in fact, I still hate the ambiguity of terms, the way it is argued in congress, and how this may be the canary before other "real" internet censorship bills get introduced.

And since this is about the dozenth SOPA article posted in the last couple weeks, and with a certainly flamebait title, I just wanted to introduce some other viewpoints and, hopefully, some rationality to the otherwise emotional discussion.

Re: SOPA: The End of the Internet as We Know it

#12

Okay I'm not going to attempt to support/defend SOPA but I have some serious questions: Why do all of these SOPA articles on HN fail to mention that this bill specifically targets "foreign" sites? They all mention a possible threat against youtube, facebook etc, but since these are "domestic" sites aren't they excluded? Is there a particular definition or qualification in the bill that I missed that would widen the s…

As I understand it, there are at least 3 different ways SOPA can affect a person/company negatively: 1. If your site gets targeted to be blocked. 2. If you run an ISP and you have to manage the infrastructure to block websites. 3. If you develop a program that could be used to route around DNS blocks, which SOPA would make illegal. So, while targeting the bill at foreign sites lessens its impact for #1, which is stil…

4. If you're one of tens of thousands of merchant account providers, payment processors and advertising networks that will have to manage the infrastructure to suspend or terminate customers whose website is accused of primarily enabling copyright infringement.

Plus, all these companies are going to end up involved in lawsuits with one or more clients over the constitutionality of being forced to breach contracts without any due process.

Post reply on HN