Live data from Hacker News

The ethics of reclining airplane seats

lesswrong.com

11–20 of 96 posts

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#11

Almost everybody does it since it's impossible to sleep on a non-reclined seat. I'm surprised this is even an issue being discussed.

I think the main argument is whether to recline on flights, say, less than 5 hours in duration. If everyone is trying to sleep on a long overnight, most everyone would like to recline

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#13
post #5

I’m in camp if they give you the option you have to assume the person in front will fully recline. No point in getting mad over it. If you want or need more space just get the premium seats if it means that much to you.

They can recline it as long as it is far from my knees. But if they need to take their space, the seat won't budge

If they need more space they can pay for a seat that reclines more then

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#16

Almost everybody does it since it's impossible to sleep on a non-reclined seat. I'm surprised this is even an issue being discussed.

Are you tall (> 6 feet)?

I think people’s policies on reclining are probably significant impacted by how uncomfortable they are if the person in front reclines, which AFAICT is much more significant for tall people than people of median height or below.

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#17

Be aware that people with bad hips, arthritis, or other such physical problems may be in a significant amount of pain without reclining. In such cases, reclining for more comfort isn't a trivial improvement - it is the difference between being able to walk or not when the flight ends. Being someone in such a category, I really do sympathize with people who are likewise made physically uncomfortable when I recline. Bu…

I’m 5-5 and medium build so I really don’t notice the difference between main and comfort+ for the most part - I often get free upgrades. But, I can imagine how much of a miserable experience it must be for someone taller or bigger in main when the seat is reclined. Being tall in this case is a “physical problem”.

And many companies that pay for or reimburse for business travel won’t reimburse for anything other than main - including the “frugal FAANG”.

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#18
post #5

I’m in camp if they give you the option you have to assume the person in front will fully recline. No point in getting mad over it. If you want or need more space just get the premium seats if it means that much to you.

They can recline it as long as it is far from my knees. But if they need to take their space, the seat won't budge If they need more space they can pay for a seat that reclines more then

Fun story: in the 1980s I flew with a co-worker on Northwest DC-10. Co-worker was a tall solid guy. Person in front tried to recline their seat into his knees. Knees prevented full recline. Person complained to FA. FA yells at my co-worker telling him he has to move his knees to facilitate full recline for person in front.

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#19
post #4

I’ve been on a few flights in which the seat reclined by swinging forward, rather than pivoting backward. So, the impact of the recline was fully experienced by the recliner, and not at all by the person in the seat behind.

that's a great idea -- though i have not experienced this myself (except in some movie theaters)

I presume such chairs are costlier to manufature and maintain -- so most cheap airlines do not opt for them

Re: The ethics of reclining airplane seats

#20

Almost everybody does it since it's impossible to sleep on a non-reclined seat. I'm surprised this is even an issue being discussed.

I assume you know it's not 'impossible'.

Not only that, but I only recline if I'm awake and have my eyes open - in response to the person in front doing so.

I don't find it a more comfortable position, but I do find the person in front adopting it an uncomfortable encroachment on my space; so I reclaim it.

Obviously others differ, since I would never recline in the emergency exit row, so if we all felt the same way nobody would have anything to recline in response to.

Post reply on HN