Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 239 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#12
>There are plenty of studies that show that having a "purpose" and working after it is correlated with higher happiness or well being.

I wouldn't even consider debating this with anyone. It's too true.

>"Purpose" is vague enough, so to make things worse I am going to conflate it with "life meaning", "calling" or "personal values".

What is the purpose of the yeast which makes bread? It is life, it has a purpose. What is the purpose of a grape vine? It is life and has a purpose.

Purpose is vague because it technically has to be simple because it's true of single celled organisms as well.

>I recently came across the Japanese "Ikigai" which seems related.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4LE5bel_GvU

Only place I've ever seen the word. Possibly the same video you found?

>Ok, I buy this, however, what is this "purpose/ meaning/ calling/ value" thing? What does it mean, really? How do I find mine?

Another great video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L-STKInWhpU

When you wake up in the morning. You could stay in bed and stay warm, but instead you jump out of bed and get dressed. You then move onto another task and another task. Imagine you're fulfilling missions. Even if they are small side missions, there is a reward in each mission. Making your bed, cleaning the garbage off the ground. Each thing does have a reward.

There will be a side mission sometime in the day which when you actually do it, it becomes your purpose. It's going to be something you would never have done. Perhaps you're in the grocery store and some old lady is struggling to grab something. You grab it for them, and its wierd, you never do this. You didnt expect anything in return but you did get a reward. Not from the lady, but you did receive a reward.

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#13
I can speak to this.

First, listen to affinity effects, but listen critically.

What I mean is: if you find that you just so happen to get along really great with haberdashers, you find yourself at haberdashery conventions, and you have an ample collection of hats: take note of this! *But let this be one factor among others.* Some of the most important, purposeful years of my life came from people and contexts I didn't think I related to at all.

Next, get yourself a bunch of free time and a space to experiment in.

Try out stuff you're curious about! For me, it was textile design, music, and calligraphy. I'm terrible at all of these things, but I never would have figured out what I do want to do, which is design & build user interfaces.

And when I do, I think a lot about how tailors make garments that feel so good and right and true, but still look amazing. This metaphor informs and enriches my software practice.

The key ingredients are time, money, safety, and space.

You need time -- no one can experiment if they have only an hour or two of freedom per day.

You need money -- no one can experiment without making purchases.

You need safety -- it has to be safe to experiment. No one innovates when the consequences of failure are homelessness and death.

And finally, you need physical space to house whatever equipment and resources you need for your explorations.

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#14
post #7

do drugs. travel alone. try lots of different kinds of jobs. good luck.

I concur. A mushroom or LSD trip in nature is the quintessential human experience and has been immensely helpful even for those than never continued use of the substance.

> A mushroom or LSD trip in nature is the quintessential human experience and has been immensely helpful even for those than never continued use of the substance

I'd like to provide a counter-example - I've never had any benefits from using LSD or shrooms. The first time I was just tripping and deluded myself into thinking I've discovered something very profound, when in fact I was looking at some basic mathematics like Fibonacci sequence and thinking thoughts like "wow this is so much similar to real life, things repeat, but they also change". Every subsequent time has been progressively worse. One time I've spent an hour feeling most depressed I've ever felt in my life while crying in a fetal position. Last time I tried shrooms, every single noise was amplified 10x and scared the shit out of me. Afterwards, it just wasn't worth trying anymore.

My best friend from high school, a very bright and intelligent young man, met a girl who was very into psychedelics. They started doing them, had lots of fun. I did it with them a few times too, mostly had a good time. At first sight, one would say that the drugs actually benefited them, made them more "open". But after some time, they internalized the stance that they were "immune to bad things" that can happen from drug abuse. Few years later, the friend ran away from home, talking about how his parents are narcissistic and abusing him (which I'm fairly sure they weren't - he told me all about his relationship with parents for years, and there's never been a single sign of narcissism or abuse in his stories, and I've personally met them, hanged out at his house, they were always nice to us and never showed a single sign of any issues), cut off his fingers with a knife, and disappeared without a trace. To this day I haven't been able to find him anywhere online, and I only hope he's alive.

Psychedelics are fun, but to say that they're "immensely helpful even for those than never continued use of the substance" is a huge generalization, requires a lot more data than most people consider to gather, and is harmful as general advice.

A better advice would be something along the lines of "try it and see how it works for you, there's a chance it might help you out".

Also, if you're depressed or anxious, avoid psychedelics, especially heavy doses. At some point it's hard not to start thinking about the white elephant, and once you start falling in the abyss, there's not much that can pull you out.

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#15
Would you be interested in another opinion?

Purpose is the reason you had your own "hero" story

The unique road you had from your birth till now gave you the strengths and uniqueness to do something you are capable of

I work with engineers to find the balance, and to identify your own calling or purpose

should you be interested, my email is in my profile and we can schedule a 22 min call

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#18
I think the words "meaning" and "calling" are a bit strong. They all kind of imply the notion that there is one thing that will make you happy and that you have to find it. In reality, I think there are lots of different (company, position) that can make you happy.

You also used the word "value", which I think is more on point.

We all have a different set of values. If you do things that are in conflict with those values, you will feel bad. So finding a job where the most important values you have are fulfilled is a key point to being happy.

I don't have any particular resource, but I think there must be a lot of books on how to find and understand those values. I personnally worked on that with a therapist.

My example :

I was working in a 45k-employee engineering service company (not sure of the english translation), where I was working on an ERP software for (military) aviation. The tech stack and the human organization was terrible.

It conflicted with some of my values (knowledge, peace, creativity, autonomy...) and was starting to make me feel anxious and angry. I also felt that what I did had no real purpose.

I knew I needed a place where kindness and knowledge were important. When I finally found that, working in a place were I feel the end product makes the world better, my life really was better.

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#19
This works: Imagine your purpose as the centre of a sphere bounded by a perimeter representing the limits of the experiences which you want in your life. Spend as long as is necessary testing the bounds of the sphere in every direction. Try loads of things, especially bonkers ones which might seem counter to your nature. Find where those boundaries lie, and then identify your purpose in the middle of it all.

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#20
From my own search on this topic:

Science can only do so much with the 'internal' meaning. All people I've read are inadequate or point to religion.

Religions, across the board, sure seems to be solely focused on purpose and meaning.

If you want purpose outside yourself, I'd look to a religion or a group that functions similarly. I dug Alan Watts and the like for awhile. More recently have liked St Augustine and other apologetics.

I know the concept religion causes raised flags but I do suggest that you are least give it an open mind while you search.

Post reply on HN