Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides

rogermexico.bearblog.dev

11–20 of 391 posts

Re: Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides

#11

You did consent to it, in the fine print. Unfortunately.

Which is why GDPR has the concept of "informed consent", which is a fancy way of saying "consent hidden in the fine print doesn't count".

And that the user may not have capacity to consent.

That seems the salient issue today with regards to children and social media. Most of the giant social media companies profit from participants who cannot legally enrol.

Re: Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides

#13
post #3

"Informed Consent is just a theory. Besides [other app] already spies on you so who cares? Whaddareya doing in PowerPoint that's so sekret?"

In our companies slides we have tons of confidential slides containing info that could be misused for insider trading by MS engineers?

Re: Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides

#14
post #5

I look forward to the day when PowerPoint is banned due to enterprise security concerns.

How about Grammarly? Or G-suite? They have access to most of the companies out there. I find it terrifying people use Grammarly and it has access to every piece of confidential word written.

Re: Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides

#16
post #9

PowerPoint has a feature where it uses machine learning to suggest layout and design changes for your content. This feature most likely can be turned off, but of course it needs some data on what's on your slide to suggest changes. I hope this submission is flagged and removed. Just because you don't like Microsoft doesn't mean such misrepresentation is okay.

So you agree that Microsoft sends the content of your Powerpoint slides (and, by extension, all DoD powerpoint slides, since they're notorious users of the application) to Microsoft?

Re: Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides

#17
post #9

PowerPoint has a feature where it uses machine learning to suggest layout and design changes for your content. This feature most likely can be turned off, but of course it needs some data on what's on your slide to suggest changes. I hope this submission is flagged and removed. Just because you don't like Microsoft doesn't mean such misrepresentation is okay.

Right; when I saw title I assumed Designer was going to be the context. I've also observed that Designer only works when I'm online, so I figured out that it uses external servers to generate suggestions.

I suppose it could/should be more obvious/explicit on the Designer pane itself, something like "This is an online feature that uses Microsoft's servers to generate recommendations", or a more user-friendly language.

Note however that the article is light on details; does it send a full content of slides? Some hash of text and images? A non-identifiable abstraction of layers involved? This could be done well or poorly.

(I don't think the submission should be flagged FWIW, but I agree that it's not of good enough quality to deserve great ranking; but that's of course subjective:)

Re: Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides

#18
post #9

PowerPoint has a feature where it uses machine learning to suggest layout and design changes for your content. This feature most likely can be turned off, but of course it needs some data on what's on your slide to suggest changes. I hope this submission is flagged and removed. Just because you don't like Microsoft doesn't mean such misrepresentation is okay.

I don't really care that it has a feature that's the reason they're sending data off to Microsoft, I care that they're sending data off to Microsoft and it's not blatantly obvious to the user.

Re: Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides

#19

> Did we consent to this? I did. I guess the author didn't read the T&Cs.

Chief Justice(of the United States) John Roberts suggested that he doesn't read them.

Trying to call people out for not doing so or not understanding the technological reason why data is sent doesn't seem productive.

Re: Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides

#20
post #16
post #9

PowerPoint has a feature where it uses machine learning to suggest layout and design changes for your content. This feature most likely can be turned off, but of course it needs some data on what's on your slide to suggest changes. I hope this submission is flagged and removed. Just because you don't like Microsoft doesn't mean such misrepresentation is okay.

So you agree that Microsoft sends the content of your Powerpoint slides (and, by extension, all DoD powerpoint slides, since they're notorious users of the application) to Microsoft?

It's implied that he does not agree since he claims that the claim is misrepresentation.
Post reply on HN