Live data from Hacker News

Gender and Age Differences in Love Styles and Attitudes

dimensional.me

11–20 of 69 posts

Re: Gender and Age Differences in Love Styles and Attitudes

#11
post #7

Apple Users only. Responses are not necessarily indicative of how the respondents will actually behave in real life.

> Responses are not necessarily indicative of how the respondents will actually behave in real life. That's the case with any response anyone gives under almost all life contexts...

Not necessarily, but it is a particular potential flaw in surveys regarding private and intimate subjects, or those affecting social status or self-perception.

Re: Gender and Age Differences in Love Styles and Attitudes

#12
post #10
post #3

What is missing here is a study of the desire to be alone.

I thought I had that desire most of my life and recently figured out that was far more about my major anxiety to be able to provide quality "service" (as the article calls it) in all relationships, from casual conversation to romantic. Obviously, there are still times I want to be alone, but I'm more aware if it's due to anxiety and try to deal with that feeling if it is. That's just what I figured out for myself, no…

That's a really powerful self-discovery. Obviously some people are more introverted than others, but introversion has more to do with how we handle (over)stimulation than it does desire for social connection and acceptance. Humans are incredibly social creatures by nature. Even the most introverted people usually want connection.

Re: Gender and Age Differences in Love Styles and Attitudes

#13
post #4

All things considered, I was expecting there to be much higher gap between genders and ages. At only one point is there more than a 10% difference. In my experience men and women claim entirely different wants and needs.

In my experience men and women's emotional levels aren't very different but how they respond to those emotions can be different because cultural context must also be navigated. In America it isn't manly to express a deep craving for cuddles, but every heterosexual woman I've met have been surprised by how touch-needy men end up being.

Re: Gender and Age Differences in Love Styles and Attitudes

#14
post #10
post #3

What is missing here is a study of the desire to be alone.

I thought I had that desire most of my life and recently figured out that was far more about my major anxiety to be able to provide quality "service" (as the article calls it) in all relationships, from casual conversation to romantic. Obviously, there are still times I want to be alone, but I'm more aware if it's due to anxiety and try to deal with that feeling if it is. That's just what I figured out for myself, no…

thanks for sharing, it's nice to see personal insight about something not related to work here.

Re: Gender and Age Differences in Love Styles and Attitudes

#15
post #9
post #4

All things considered, I was expecting there to be much higher gap between genders and ages. At only one point is there more than a 10% difference. In my experience men and women claim entirely different wants and needs.

The differences between men and women are usually not as dramatic as standup comedy and television make them out to be. The differences aren't dramatic, but they are statistically significant.

Or any other social institution for that matter: religion, newspapers, families, schools, sports, &c. Social institutions are fundamental or at the very least complicit in the legitimization of the social mechanisms of typification. That is to say, licensing the idea and practice that individual behavior can be simplified to types.

We all know the dangers of using oversimplified models in other contexts, but the same applies here and happens to be one of the largest generators of present conflict. It's a classic map-territory problem applied to people themselves and - whether the map makers know this or not - those who control the maps can sometimes also control the territory.

Re: Gender and Age Differences in Love Styles and Attitudes

#16
post #10
post #3

What is missing here is a study of the desire to be alone.

I thought I had that desire most of my life and recently figured out that was far more about my major anxiety to be able to provide quality "service" (as the article calls it) in all relationships, from casual conversation to romantic. Obviously, there are still times I want to be alone, but I'm more aware if it's due to anxiety and try to deal with that feeling if it is. That's just what I figured out for myself, no…

A good thought experiment here would be: If you were magically assured that the other people would be thrilled to be around you, find all your jokes funny, etc (fill in your own fantasies), would you still want to be alone?

That distinguishes between "I truly want to be alone" and "I want to be alone because I am not the person I wish I were".

Re: Gender and Age Differences in Love Styles and Attitudes

#17
post #6
post #4

All things considered, I was expecting there to be much higher gap between genders and ages. At only one point is there more than a 10% difference. In my experience men and women claim entirely different wants and needs.

It's a meta-study based on already "summed-up" attributes, so at least two levels of information loss. And it's hardly qualitative. It can easily say, "both want X", but not touch at all "how" they express this want, or how they perceive X.

> or how they perceive X.

Yes, giving identical labels to very different phenomena is a big problem in this kind of survey-based approach.

On Maggie McNeill's blog, one post touched on the idea that women want sex to last longer. She pointed out that women do frequently say this, but what they mean is that they want foreplay to last longer.

Re: Gender and Age Differences in Love Styles and Attitudes

#19
Does "gender gap" here matter more than what larger fractions show? For example, they say "women desire more Affirmation" but 49% have it as a top two while 56% have "time" in the top two. Men also have 54% for time in the top two. I feel like that's more interesting than looking at percentage differences (which tbh don't really seem to matter that much for this statistic).

EDIT: a striking example of this, they say "women give more gifts" in terms of LL they express, as a finding. But only 32% have this as a top two expressed LL, so a good majority of women don't even have gifts as a top two expressed LL. So, who cares about the percent difference 8%, does it matter? What does it even mean? What if 1% of men did X vs 9% of women? Why would the interesting takeaway be "wow, women are more likely than men to do X!!" vs. "gee, a sheer minority of people do X at all."

Saying the words "women are more likely than men to do X" leaves the reader unfortunately with the impression "many women do X," whereas that might not be true.

Re: Gender and Age Differences in Love Styles and Attitudes

#20
post #18

Apple Users only. Responses are not necessarily indicative of how the respondents will actually behave in real life.

Would you date a non Apple user? Perhaps someone who doesn’t even have a phone?

Eww, dating a green bubble is gross.
Post reply on HN