Live data from Hacker News

GitHub-Next

githubnext.com

11–20 of 119 posts

Re: GitHub-Next

#11
post #5

Did GitHub ever respond to the concerns about CoPilot? Specifically whether they trained it on private repos or GPL?

copilot is just a prototype. imagine in 10-20 years, software engineers as we know it will be obsolete.

Lots of other languages, tools, libraries, and frameworks have already made SWEs orders of magnitude more productive over the course of the last 40+ years. I don't think there's any indication of the field shrinking or slowing down as a result of that though.

Re: GitHub-Next

#13
post #7

Could they use the blurb of text at the top to give me like... a noun to describe what this is? It just says some vagueness about the future and investigating and exploring. Is it a conference? A team? An initiative? How does it work? Whatever this is supposed to be selling me on, they're doing a terrible job because I can't figure out what it is!

It seems to be a research team within GitHub based on the blurb, projects, and team.

Re: GitHub-Next

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It was trained on all public repos, and only public repos. They did not pay attention to licensing.

Wow, that's crazy. Do we have something official that says as much?

It's infuriating, when you are large enough you can get away with anything when it comes to copyright violations but I remember the crazy pushback on things like format and time shifting against private individuals.

Re: GitHub-Next

#16
If anyone on the team at GitHub who built this site sees this --

Heads up, that page has no `` tag so the browser tab is `githubnext.com/`. That is a _VERY_ minor nit, but still an SEO ding (you're github, that doesn't matter much), and a rough edge that could be buffed out.

Bonus points for adding a favicon too. :)

Re: GitHub-Next

#17
post #7

Could they use the blurb of text at the top to give me like... a noun to describe what this is? It just says some vagueness about the future and investigating and exploring. Is it a conference? A team? An initiative? How does it work? Whatever this is supposed to be selling me on, they're doing a terrible job because I can't figure out what it is!

From Twitter bio: "GitHub Next: a team exploring the future of technology and software beyond the adjacent-possible." https://twitter.com/githubnext

Their team consists of engineers and researchers.

Re: GitHub-Next

#18
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's such a vague and novel area, that I don't think lawyers will recommend/allow commenting on it unless required by court of law. There is no precedent on if a computer reading your code or looking at the image is fair-use or not.

why not train it on copyright material also? whats the prima-facie reason for not doing so? i mean if you are doing "all public repos", why not everything else?

They did train it on copyrighted work. The GPL is a license for copyrighted work. If it wasn't copyrighted, a license would be useless.

The code being covered by copyright and the code being publicly accessible are two different things.

Re: GitHub-Next

#19
co-pilot used to generate react code with a GUI visualization tool. Boy am I excited for the amount of money people will be paying for ongoing maintenance for this brave new world.
Post reply on HN