Live data from Hacker News

Hypothes.is: Taking peer review to the Internet

kickstarter.com

11–14 of 14 posts

Re: Hypothes.is: Taking peer review to the Internet

#11

Initially I thought this would be a free system for paper publishing which would let all new papers published to be available in public domain. Why doesnt such a thing exist by the way?

I've had this same thought many times.

You're not the only one - this idea has been done before, google "The Third Voice" for the details.

it was apretty big deal back in 1999 - http://blog.collins.net.pr/2011/11/httphypothesis.html

Re: Hypothes.is: Taking peer review to the Internet

#12

Initially I thought this would be a free system for paper publishing which would let all new papers published to be available in public domain. Why doesnt such a thing exist by the way?

Well, there's http://arxiv.org .

And of course, anyone can put anything they want on the internet, which is a form of publishing into the public domain. If you mean, publish in such a way as to get read and become part of the academic literature, that's another story.

Re: Hypothes.is: Taking peer review to the Internet

#13
post #4

It's a great vision, but their website does not disclose how will they implement it better than existing similar projects.

Their response to this concern on the FAQ at Kickstarter is as follows: "No one has yet made an effective attempt to leverage the strengths of the Internet to improve the quality of information we consume, at the place that we consume it. In essence, we are bringing crowd-sourced peer-review to the event horizon where information is produced—the thousands of news sites and blogs on the Internet. To encourage quality,…

Or http:://marginize.com , whatever happened to that?

Re: Hypothes.is: Taking peer review to the Internet

#14
post #12

Initially I thought this would be a free system for paper publishing which would let all new papers published to be available in public domain. Why doesnt such a thing exist by the way?

Well, there's http://arxiv.org . And of course, anyone can put anything they want on the internet, which is a form of publishing into the public domain. If you mean, publish in such a way as to get read and become part of the academic literature, that's another story.

I'm talking about fully peer reviewed with conferences and the whole shebang ... Its really the only way to get that knowledge out into the public domain.
Post reply on HN