Live data from Hacker News

Why Medium Failed

theverge.com

11–15 of 15 posts

Re: Why Medium Failed

#11
post #4

My list of reasons Medium failed. - Their in-site discovery sucked. Like many users I would discovered Medium articles via external networks, but once on the site, I never found their "similar articles" feature to give my anything worthwhile. Also their editorialized recommendations seemed to have a hidden social-political agenda. But what media platform doesn't? - Most of the content had quality barely above a tweet…

> No one wanted to invest in reading a 45 minute article

Honestly, I was/am quite the opposite kind of person: I mostly went to Medium for this kind of long reads. When the articles typically became shorter, I became much less interested in reading them - as you described:

> Turns out you can't say much in 10 minutes that wouldn't be a better Tweet. This lead to a race to the bottom in terms of article quality and length.

Re: Why Medium Failed

#13
post #11
post #4

My list of reasons Medium failed. - Their in-site discovery sucked. Like many users I would discovered Medium articles via external networks, but once on the site, I never found their "similar articles" feature to give my anything worthwhile. Also their editorialized recommendations seemed to have a hidden social-political agenda. But what media platform doesn't? - Most of the content had quality barely above a tweet…

> No one wanted to invest in reading a 45 minute article Honestly, I was/am quite the opposite kind of person: I mostly went to Medium for this kind of long reads. When the articles typically became shorter, I became much less interested in reading them - as you described: > Turns out you can't say much in 10 minutes that wouldn't be a better Tweet. This lead to a race to the bottom in terms of article quality and le…

While I agree, long form content is almost exclusively better, it can be daunting. Medium was great as a quick scroll/dopamine hit, and long form goes against that. Also many long form articles are only made long via meandering threads, injected personal anecdotes, and literal filler. Strip that away, and it ends up closer to a Medium article. It takes great effort to write a long article that actually benefits from being long.

Re: Why Medium Failed

#14
post #7

Medium is great for IT related articles. Why is everyone complaining? Is there another source of good software dev/architecture articles that everyone is going to for quality content?

dev.to

Dev.to has become littered with articles regurgitating popular project's documentation examples, unfortunately. Medium has this problem to an extent, but discoverability on dev.to has become increasingly difficult due to low effort spam

Re: Why Medium Failed

#15
post #2

I’m convinced Medium failed the second they considered themselves more than a blogging platform. Initially it was a very well designed blog as-a-service but they kept shovelling on features and wanted to be a destination in its own right. If they removed the free tier and doubled down on providing a best-in-class white label blogging platform, they might not be in as bad a position as they are today. Greed’s a mother…

> more than a blogging platform

Can you please explain this a bit?

Post reply on HN