Live data from Hacker News

Prostitution and Spam Killed Craigslist

ashlan.com

11–20 of 68 posts

Re: Prostitution and Spam Killed Craigslist

#11
The thing that killed craigslist was a bunch of startups that took it's ideas and charged 5% for the transaction and lip service about how it is safer than "other platforms" (other platforms being craigslist).

Not saying that's good or bad, but that's what killed craigslist.

Re: Prostitution and Spam Killed Craigslist

#12
post #4

I think Facebook's introduction of Marketplace is what killed Craigslist.

I created a burner Facebook account just to use Marketplace. On day 0 I'm told that I can't use Marketplace 'yet.' Every day for a few weeks I login and check and get the same message. Sometime at the 3-4 week mark I'm told I need to add a phone number or my account will be disabled. Back to craigslist/nextdoor/etc Edit: My fault for using a loaded term like 'burner'. I don't have a facebook account. I created a 'rea…

It's amazing that it's possible to create "burner" accounts but my 15 year old account was banned twice for trying to authenticate oculus software so I could root an Oculus Go using John Carmack's technique. I gave up on getting unbanned after the second banning and haven't looked back.

Re: Prostitution and Spam Killed Craigslist

#13
post #4

I think Facebook's introduction of Marketplace is what killed Craigslist.

It's the other way around. The only reason Facebook Marketplace is thriving is because of how shitty the alternative had become. Facebook's other recent product launches (like dating) haven't had close to the same reception because people saw no reason to switch.

Re: Prostitution and Spam Killed Craigslist

#15
post #2

I don't have this experience, and regularly use Craigslist to buy and sell as I always have. Admittedly I never used it for social purposes since there were always other options, so maybe that piece took a hit over the years.

Craiglist is still going strong in rural areas for country things. My wife bought a goat on Craigslist lately.

Re: Prostitution and Spam Killed Craigslist

#16
post #2

I don't have this experience, and regularly use Craigslist to buy and sell as I always have. Admittedly I never used it for social purposes since there were always other options, so maybe that piece took a hit over the years.

I’ve noticed the volume of actual useful stuff for sale is lower than in the past, I think due to Facebook Marketplace. Facebook doesn’t offer anything better, just constant advertisement since it’s right there on the same website people are on to serve their social media addiction.

FB market place fucking suuucks.

The few times I've posted stuff, I was inundated with phishing attacks. I was talking to a friend about it, and he actually fell for one of the attacks and had to spend a shit load of time getting his phone number back after they stole it. I actually found guidance from, I think, the FCC on what to do if you're the victim of this. Suggesting that this is a serious problem that FB isn't effectively dealing with.

CL all day, especially for the kind of stuff I buy and sell.

Re: Prostitution and Spam Killed Craigslist

#17
The title of this article should have also included trafficking. While it has an overlap with prostitution, it is a heinous, misunderstood, and overlooked issue. It was also the primary reason for why Craigslist removed the Personals section.

The Department of Homeland Security has a great section on their website about human trafficking, what it is, how to identify it, how to report it, and so on:

https://www.dhs.gov/blue-campaign/what-human-trafficking

Also, Girls Educational & Mentoring Services (GEMS) has been doing a great job at not just helping to raise awareness of the issue, but also has directly helped trafficking victims get out of dangerous situations and back onto healthy paths in life:

https://www.gems-girls.org/

Re: Prostitution and Spam Killed Craigslist

#18

The thing that killed craigslist was a bunch of startups that took it's ideas and charged 5% for the transaction and lip service about how it is safer than "other platforms" (other platforms being craigslist). Not saying that's good or bad, but that's what killed craigslist.

I doubt this -- starting means developing the user experience (phone friendly probably) and also getting people to hear about it (marketing). Both are hard, what you say is the easy part.

Re: Prostitution and Spam Killed Craigslist

#19
I used to offload my used stuff on Craigslist. I was swamped with people intentionally trying to waste my time only to be lowballed at the last minute. Out of principal I would always tell them to F* off. I used to take adds down after the first person who agreed to buy it, these days the ads stays up until the money is in my hand, and I insta block anyone who tries to negotiate. Often it’s still too much of a hassle so I just donate it to charity.
Post reply on HN