Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Bend (YC S22) – Automatically measure your company's carbon footprint

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 99 posts

Re: Launch HN: Bend (YC S22) – Automatically measure your company's carbon footprint

#11
post #9

What’s the carbon footprint of $100 bend subscription? It would be neat if carbon footprint could be translated to some more humanized unit. Like trees or global warming degrees or idk. Also, it seems like some products at companies would be more carbon friendly. Would be nice if you could categorize the spending within a bank line item. Naive example… I bought a $10 reusable cup from my local coffee shop so that eve…

Anyone can translate carbon footprint into trees or whatever. The important part is having a metric so you can make sure it's going down, not up.

+1!

Re: Launch HN: Bend (YC S22) – Automatically measure your company's carbon footprint

#12

What’s the carbon footprint of $100 bend subscription? It would be neat if carbon footprint could be translated to some more humanized unit. Like trees or global warming degrees or idk. Also, it seems like some products at companies would be more carbon friendly. Would be nice if you could categorize the spending within a bank line item. Naive example… I bought a $10 reusable cup from my local coffee shop so that eve…

We are offsetting all our emissions via the Bend Offsets Plan, so the carbon footprint of your $100 Bend subscription is credibly net-zero :)

And yes, line-item and other "level 3" data is very exciting to us techies—unfortunately it's also really difficult to access! One of the reasons we like the Bend model is that it simplifies/abstracts away from that by looking at your total contribution to a company's bottom-line as the source of truth for emissions, which prevents a kind of "line item greenwashing."

But yes, in the future it would be nifty to sync in level 3 data from receipts or something to factor that into our calculations!

Re: Launch HN: Bend (YC S22) – Automatically measure your company's carbon footprint

#14
post #5

I’m not an economist by profession but I suspect (and at some point want to try and model) that one’s carbon footprint is just a linear function of three variables: the amount of money spent, the fraction of all money that’s in active circulation in the economy, and the fraction of clean energy in the total economy. If you pay google 100 bucks, and See how google spends that money: it saves some, pays off its employe…

I like the way you're thinkin'! That's a very "Bend-onomics" mindset, if I can be so presumptive. That calculation is not dissimilar from what we do on a merchant-level, and I think it's a good, macro-comparison! For your three variables, we just substitute 1) transaction amount, 2) vendor revenue, and 3) vendor emissions, if that makes sense. There are many reasons why it's important to do this at the merchant level…

Ya totally! Another way to think about it — in climate lingo, there are 3 types of emissions: First there are Scope 1 emissions, which are the emissions from burning fossil fuels directly (gas in your car, natural gas for your stove, etc.). Then there are Scope 2 emissions, which are from energy (you buy electricity from utilities, and those utilities use some percentage of non-renewable generation, like coal or natural gas). And finally Scope 3 is everything else — all the goods and services you buy, upstream and downstream.

But I think the point you guys are making, is that actually everything is Scope 1 emissions plus some number of hops. So if you buy gas, that's 0 hops. If you buy energy from your utility, and they use natural gas, that's 1 hop. If you buy an ice cream that was made in a factory powered by natural gas, that's 2 hops. And if you buy that ice cream with a cone, purchased by the ice cream shop, that was manufactured in a factory ... etc.

The problem is, consumers are often the ones who apply the pressure to address climate (don't wait for the fossil fuel companies to take this on themselves). And so we need to trace back all those upstream emissions, all the way back to those Scope 1 emissions, to really size the impact, and align incentives to decarbonize.

Historically, climate programs only focused on Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions. But that only addresses maybe 20% of emissions for most companies. This is why it's critical to consider the impact of all the goods and services your company purchases.

Re: Launch HN: Bend (YC S22) – Automatically measure your company's carbon footprint

#15
post #13

Are there any emerging standards or agreement on exactly how to measure carbon footprint?

Ya, the Greenhouse Gas Protocol — https://ghgprotocol.org/ — is the universally accepted way for companies to measure their emissions. It's been around for about a decade.

That being said, the Greenhouse Gas Protocol reporting has been pretty inconsistent in the past. Companies cherry-pick and leave out important info, or define their 'reporting boundary' in inconsistent ways. One of our goals is to help 'debug' these inconsistencies.

Lucas Joppa from Microsoft laid this out quite well here: https://www.ted.com/talks/lucas_joppa_how_to_fix_the_bugs_in...

Re: Launch HN: Bend (YC S22) – Automatically measure your company's carbon footprint

#17
post #16

Man, I grew up in a city called Bend and my family still lives there. Your company name is really tripping me out.

Bend, Oregon?

I'm from Seattle, but I've actually wanted to visit Bend for a while. Seems like a nice river town

Re: Launch HN: Bend (YC S22) – Automatically measure your company's carbon footprint

#20
post #16

Man, I grew up in a city called Bend and my family still lives there. Your company name is really tripping me out.

Bend, Oregon? I'm from Seattle, but I've actually wanted to visit Bend for a while. Seems like a nice river town

Exactly. It's an amazing place. Definitely go visit it.
Post reply on HN