Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report

time.com

11–20 of 60 posts

Re: Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report

#11
I guess America cares about India's human rights record now that India is trading with Russia and doesn't back Ukraine unconditionally. You coud totally see this coming once India started trading with Russia.

The Indian government, and especially the current government, has been treating muslims terribly for years. But the American establishment didn't have a problem with it until India declared they wouldn't go along with Russian sanctions.

Re: Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report

#12

I guess America cares about India's human rights record now that India is trading with Russia and doesn't back Ukraine unconditionally. You coud totally see this coming once India started trading with Russia. The Indian government, and especially the current government, has been treating muslims terribly for years. But the American establishment didn't have a problem with it until India declared they wouldn't go alon…

Even US is trading with Russia.

Re: Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report

#13
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I don't see how Assuming you intend to see, you can see how if you read the article and its linked articles.

I'm only referring to the specific case of the members of the ruling party allegedly making calls for violence. There is nothing in the article that says these were made on Facebook.

From the articles:

"religious violence fomented in India across Meta’s platforms.”

"Facebook allowed a Hindu nationalist conspiracy theory to flourish on its platform"

"One video of an extremist preacher calling for Hindus to rise up and kill Muslims racked up 1.4 million views but was not deleted"

"Facebook banned a Hindu extremist group under its terrorism policies—but left most of its pages online for months after that ban, allowing them to share content"

"In Facebook posts and public appearances, Indian politician T. Raja Singh has said Rohingya Muslim immigrants should be shot, called Muslims traitors and threatened to raze mosques. [FB employees] concluded Mr. Singh not only had violated the company’s hate-speech rules "

"The company’s top public-policy executive in the country, Ankhi Das, opposed applying the hate-speech rules to Mr. Singh and at least three other Hindu nationalist individuals and groups flagged internally for promoting or participating in violence, said the current and former employees."

"team took no action after BJP politicians posted content accusing Muslims of intentionally spreading the coronavirus, plotting against the nation and waging a “love jihad” campaign by seeking to marry Hindu women"

"He has used Facebook, where his own page and those dedicated to him have more than 400,000 followers, to say that Muslims who kill cows—animals revered by Hindus—should be slaughtered like them."

"Another BJP legislator, a member of Parliament named Anantkumar Hegde, has posted essays and cartoons to his Facebook page alleging that Muslims are spreading Covid-19 in the country in a conspiracy to wage “Corona Jihad.”"

"Within hours of the videotaped message, which Mr. Mishra uploaded to Facebook, rioting broke out that left dozens of people dead. Most of the victims were Muslims, and some of their killings were organized via Facebook’s WhatsApp, according to court documents filed by police and published in Indian newspapers."

Re: Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report

#14

I guess America cares about India's human rights record now that India is trading with Russia and doesn't back Ukraine unconditionally. You coud totally see this coming once India started trading with Russia. The Indian government, and especially the current government, has been treating muslims terribly for years. But the American establishment didn't have a problem with it until India declared they wouldn't go alon…

Even US is trading with Russia.

That's what selective enforcement is all about

Re: Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report

#15

I guess America cares about India's human rights record now that India is trading with Russia and doesn't back Ukraine unconditionally. You coud totally see this coming once India started trading with Russia. The Indian government, and especially the current government, has been treating muslims terribly for years. But the American establishment didn't have a problem with it until India declared they wouldn't go alon…

[deleted]

Re: Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report

#16

> Ankhi Das, Facebook’s most senior executive in India, resigned in October 2020 after the Wall Street Journal reported she had intervened to prevent the platform removing accounts of members of the country’s Hindu nationalist ruling party, some of whom had called for violence against India’s Muslim minority. I am not sure it is Facebook’s place to be policing members of the government of the largest democracy in the…

So… you’re in favor of providing a platform to call for violence against ethnic minorities?

Isn't that the US free speech ideal? Didn't the ACLU use to defend the right of KKK members to hold rallies for exactly this ideal?

Re: Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report

#17

I guess America cares about India's human rights record now that India is trading with Russia and doesn't back Ukraine unconditionally. You coud totally see this coming once India started trading with Russia. The Indian government, and especially the current government, has been treating muslims terribly for years. But the American establishment didn't have a problem with it until India declared they wouldn't go alon…

What do you mean treating muslims terribly?

Re: Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report

#18

I guess America cares about India's human rights record now that India is trading with Russia and doesn't back Ukraine unconditionally. You coud totally see this coming once India started trading with Russia. The Indian government, and especially the current government, has been treating muslims terribly for years. But the American establishment didn't have a problem with it until India declared they wouldn't go alon…

India is getting an exemption from Russian sanctions because they're considered a counter-weight to China.

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/us-house-of-representatives-...

Re: Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report

#19

I guess America cares about India's human rights record now that India is trading with Russia and doesn't back Ukraine unconditionally. You coud totally see this coming once India started trading with Russia. The Indian government, and especially the current government, has been treating muslims terribly for years. But the American establishment didn't have a problem with it until India declared they wouldn't go alon…

Facebook is not being accused by "the American establishment". They are being accused by private people, many of them not from the US.

Re: Facebook Accused of ‘Whitewashing’ India Human Rights Report

#20
post #7

> Ankhi Das, Facebook’s most senior executive in India, resigned in October 2020 after the Wall Street Journal reported she had intervened to prevent the platform removing accounts of members of the country’s Hindu nationalist ruling party, some of whom had called for violence against India’s Muslim minority. I am not sure it is Facebook’s place to be policing members of the government of the largest democracy in the…

In what way is that "policing"?

In many parts of the world Facebook is synonymous to Internet. If you can't post on Facebook, you're pretty much toasted as a public figure.
Post reply on HN