Live data from Hacker News

Taking action against scraping for hire

about.fb.com

11–20 of 240 posts

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#13
This is different from LinkedIn v HiQ because HiQ was only scraping publicly available data that was generally accessible to the broader internet. In these two cases, the data is being scraped from FB/Insta using credentials that the client handed over or the mass creation of accounts solely for scraping purposes.

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#15
>Octopus, a US subsidiary of a Chinese national high-tech enterprise, built a cloud-based platform designed to provide paying customers access to on-demand scraping software and services.

It is interesting as how they try to position this as a Chinese attack on them.

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#16
Of course, Facebook wants to make it sound like scraping is illegal, when it generally isn't.

But account hijacking and mass-creation of accounts just to access private pages are clear violations of the Facebook and Instagram ToS, so they surely can sue for that.

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#18

They are will using fb.com domain? I though meta is not FaceBook?....

I think it's like Google vs Alphabet. Alphabet is the parent company like Meta.

As for why their domain is facebook for their news site, not sure why. It would make for sense for it to be under meta instead.

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#19
post #3

Data harvesting is moral for me, but not for thee.

In general I agree that harvesting public data is moral. I think that in these particular cases it's: 1) extracting data from profiles that opted for not being public (only available to logged in users) and 2) reposting scraped data (publicly?) as belonging to the guy who scraped it without users consent.

The state of "opted for not being public" and 'available to any system authenticated person' seem contradictory.

I appreciate that 'system authenticated person' is a smaller set than those who can access anything publicly accessible, and that the former is a subset of the latter.

Post reply on HN