Live data from Hacker News

Desantis signs bill req. FL students, professors to register political views

salon.com

11–20 of 43 posts

Re: Desantis signs bill req. FL students, professors to register political views

#11
post #8

People should challenge this law in court and shot it down. One’s political view is none of the business of a state government, period.

Passing obviously illegal laws to be struck down by courts is how the right has been driving their angry voter base for decades. This is just part of the show, and having the court strike it down is a necessary part of the strategy.

No post body was provided.

Re: Desantis signs bill req. FL students, professors to register political views

#14
post #9

People should challenge this law in court and shot it down. One’s political view is none of the business of a state government, period.

The state (thru taxes) is funding the universities, right? Speaking for myself, if I was funding a university I would do things to encourage intellectual diversity. I’m more sympathetic to the more general view that education is not the business of state governments, period.

Intellectual diversity imposed upon universities (rather than being some quasi-constitutional thing to sue over) is in my view solely of use to grifters and morons. It sounds like a nice idea but it's so easily manipulated (especially by politicians looking to signal to their base rather than actually fix something even out of naivete)

Re: Desantis signs bill req. FL students, professors to register political views

#15
post #9

People should challenge this law in court and shot it down. One’s political view is none of the business of a state government, period.

The state (thru taxes) is funding the universities, right? Speaking for myself, if I was funding a university I would do things to encourage intellectual diversity. I’m more sympathetic to the more general view that education is not the business of state governments, period.

> if I was funding a university I would do things to encourage intellectual diversity.

The first amendment prohibits the state from doing such a thing. They must allow diversity of opinion, they cannot require it (this would be silly, where does it end, Edwards v. Aguillard and Kitzmiller v. Dover seem pretty clear on this).

Re: Desantis signs bill req. FL students, professors to register political views

#17
post #8

People should challenge this law in court and shot it down. One’s political view is none of the business of a state government, period.

Passing obviously illegal laws to be struck down by courts is how the right has been driving their angry voter base for decades. This is just part of the show, and having the court strike it down is a necessary part of the strategy.

Now do “common-sense gun control”. Politicians of all stripes do this because it works.

Re: Desantis signs bill req. FL students, professors to register political views

#18
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article points to https://www.tampabay.com/news/florida-politics/2021/06/22/st... , which says: In his continued push against the “indoctrination” of students, Gov. Ron DeSantis on Tuesday signed legislation that will require public universities and colleges to survey students, faculty and staff about their beliefs and viewpoints to support “intellectual diversity.”

Text from the law in the linked article: >The State Board of Education shall require each Florida College System institution to conduct an annual assessment of the intellectual freedom and viewpoint diversity at that institution. The State Board of Education shall select or create an objective, nonpartisan, and statistically valid survey to be used by each institution which considers the extent to which competing ide…

It's midterm (political not academic) season.

Re: Desantis signs bill req. FL students, professors to register political views

#19

People should challenge this law in court and shot it down. One’s political view is none of the business of a state government, period.

I think this is a bad law, but what specific legal theory could be used to challenge it in court? Please cite the specific section of the law that is in violation of the US Constitution or federal law?

Re: Desantis signs bill req. FL students, professors to register political views

#20
Some people sound more and more desperate each day for provoking people to riot. The more angry, the better. Why do they do this? and why now? This is the good question.

I would assume (I'm just speculating) that the goal is to make the Capitol assault look better by comparison. Or sell the idea that it was antifa, or galvanize their own forces again under the "them or us", "kill or be killed" etc... idea.

If everybody is rioting, nobody is. At some point you can't jail everybody and a general pardon could be proposed as the only realistic solution.

But is just one silly idea.

Maybe to divert the focus from Russia creating mass shootings, stampedes and all kind of problems inside? Another stupid idea.

A very delicate period in the US history, for sure, but if people remains smart and cold can be navigated.

Post reply on HN