Live data from Hacker News

New California law requires high schools to start later

apnews.com

11–20 of 267 posts

Re: New California law requires high schools to start later

#12
post #9

8:30 or later. Good. I say start it at 10. Let the kids sleep in and be happier for it.

That won't work for young kids if the parents have to go to work by 9.

If a high schooler needs to be driven to school by their parent, there is a serious street safety/transit problem which should be solved.

Re: New California law requires high schools to start later

#13
post #6

8:30 or later. Good. I say start it at 10. Let the kids sleep in and be happier for it.

Yeah, because they won't just stay up later then.

Some of them may, but many more will wake up comfortably due to more sunshine flooding through the window.

Re: New California law requires high schools to start later

#14
post #9

8:30 or later. Good. I say start it at 10. Let the kids sleep in and be happier for it.

That won't work for young kids if the parents have to go to work by 9.

This is for high school. But not all high schoolers are responsible enough, so still a point. Also, the majority of people have to be at work at 8am or earlier.

Re: New California law requires high schools to start later

#15
post #10

8:30 or later. Good. I say start it at 10. Let the kids sleep in and be happier for it.

Ten sounds like a nightmare for working parents. Eight seems like a completely reasonable start time to me, yet this law prevents that. Schools should be able to decide for themselves based off of the parents and what works for those in the district.

That's because the law is based around what's been observed behaviorally/biologically. Not what's good for working parents

Schools shouldn't be forcing developing humans into a schedule that impairs their ability to learn and function, no matter what they want to decide

Re: New California law requires high schools to start later

#16
post #8
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, because they won't just stay up later then.

Their parents will still likely wake them up when they go off to work.

I am VERY close to this situation, I'm married to a California teacher. Most of the kids hate this idea.

1. They know they and everyone else will just stay up later. 2. School will go on too late in the day, sports participation is dropping appreciably. 3. Those who work after school or school/sports are quitting sports to work, and planning ways to leave when they did previously to go to work.

This is incredibly short-sighted, and will not last a year.

Re: New California law requires high schools to start later

#18
post #12
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That won't work for young kids if the parents have to go to work by 9.

If a high schooler needs to be driven to school by their parent, there is a serious street safety/transit problem which should be solved.

I think the bigger issue is unsupervised minors. Not all high schoolers are mature enough to be left alone and go to school. I suppose this could be solved by pre-care, but that make this bill completely moot.
Post reply on HN