> Does anybody else have the feeling HN somehow became "programmer news" along the way? I think it's clear from Paul Graham's essays that he always basically defined "hacking" as just programming. He then created Hacker News. > Then it became "Hacker News" and about "Anything that good hackers would find interesting". Well, yes. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html *What to Submit* On-Topic: Anything that…
Has Hacker New Become Programmer News?
11–20 of 27 posts
Re: Has Hacker New Become Programmer News?
#12Re: Has Hacker New Become Programmer News?
#13I say all this because of all the communities I have found online, this one feels the most at home. And I’m the most distant person from “normal” I know. This community is great, I learn things everyday. Whatever it is and whatever it is turning into, I hope it keeps the spirit I see on it everyday.
Re: Has Hacker New Become Programmer News?
#14Re: Has Hacker New Become Programmer News?
#15I know the mods were not intending to cause this to happen, but they seem to have taken their mission a bit too seriously and extended their wrath onto anyone playing devil's advocate or posting too rapidly, etc.
Now HN has a much more sterile, corporate feel. Before the change, politics was occasionally discussed in a mostly mature and friendly way, and unhelpful comments were simply downvoted without the "help" of moderators.
Censorship and strict "community standards" about what is considered an appropriate vs inappropriate opinion, and what comment style is considered acceptable (to mods) has become the norm.
Fortunately, HN can still do a pretty good job of covering programming related topics and some startup-relevant stuff, but the old HN, the place where I often found my mind getting changed by an insightful comment or a dialog between others, seems to be gone forever.
Re: Has Hacker New Become Programmer News?
#16> Maybe a community where you have to show what you are building before you can enter? What a curious filter. Personally I'm not a fan of gatekeeping like that. Unless it was very carefully overseen it could become really toxic. Though I suppose the value is that it would filter out folks who talk a big game with little to show for it.
Re: Has Hacker New Become Programmer News?
#17This is a new inversion to me. The common complaint used to be that HN has become too much of a startup hustler site and strayed away from its programming roots, as in: “Back in the good old days you’d have the front page full of Erlang articles only”
Re: Has Hacker New Become Programmer News?
#18HN has always been a Startup site, but us programmer geeks also have interest in tech. Now people post their projects and don't even explain what they are or anything, and regular news shows up here too.. why?
Re: Has Hacker New Become Programmer News?
#19The inevitable question to ask, taking a cursory glance at your own contributions, is why would such a community accept you as a member? You seem like exactly the kind of 'normie' you're complaining about. You want to hang out with founders and makers? What's your startup? What have you made? Where's your Github profile? Show us your whitepaper on something technical, and how many citations you have. Did you even win the Putnam?
I mean, your last submission was asking about hiring a social media manager on Fiverr, come on.