Live data from Hacker News

Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

shotcut.org

11–20 of 99 posts

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#11

Anyone use this? Opinions?

I used both Shotcut and Davinci Resolve on MacOS. Shotcut provided the perfect amount of middle ground between iMovie and all the power user stuff in Davinci. More importantly, Shotcut worked well on my 2014 Macbook Pro with 8GB RAM and 128GB storage. Davinci is probably the better software but it ran very slowly once you added a couple of video/audio/photo layers. And the storage it ate up inside project files to store the cache was unbelievable. 30GB+ for for a 10 min 1080p video.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#12
Shotcut has this one cool feature [1] - drop a bunch of pictures into it and it'll create an animated slide show automatically. I've looked for ways to automate that via something like ffmpeg, but haven't found any better options.

[1] https://forum.shotcut.org/t/slideshow-generator/19162

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#13

Anyone use this? Opinions?

It's free. It actually has quite a lot of functions, and effects, but the UI/UX is so so in my opinion. Video rendering and export is fast enough which is a good thing, even when using effects. The real test with most of these authoring tools is text support and how comprehensive it is, or not, as titling is an important aspect of video editing.

> The real test with most of these authoring tools is text support

So how's the text support?

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#14

Anyone use this? Opinions?

For me, Shotcut, Openshot, Flowblade, Olive and Pitivi have been crashing to often to be worth using. Openshot used to be less flaky when I used it a few years ago when it was in GTK but the Qt version has not been stable to me.

Kdenlive is amazing though, especially the timegraphs for applying effects, and the clip proxying which makes it amazingly smooth for large projects on old laptops. I don't think any of the other free video editors come anywhere close.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#15

Shotcut has this one cool feature [1] - drop a bunch of pictures into it and it'll create an animated slide show automatically. I've looked for ways to automate that via something like ffmpeg, but haven't found any better options. [1] https://forum.shotcut.org/t/slideshow-generator/19162

ffmpeg has an entire page in their wiki devoted to slideshows: https://trac.ffmpeg.org/wiki/Slideshow

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#16

Shotcut has this one cool feature [1] - drop a bunch of pictures into it and it'll create an animated slide show automatically. I've looked for ways to automate that via something like ffmpeg, but haven't found any better options. [1] https://forum.shotcut.org/t/slideshow-generator/19162

ffmpeg has an entire page in their wiki devoted to slideshows: https://trac.ffmpeg.org/wiki/Slideshow

There is so much value in doing this in a normal application with a UI that lets you see what you're doing. ffmpeg is a fantastic utility if you already know what you need, but it's absolutely terrible for jobs where you need to be able to see and do things between the two states of "having input" and "having final output".

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#17

Shotcut has this one cool feature [1] - drop a bunch of pictures into it and it'll create an animated slide show automatically. I've looked for ways to automate that via something like ffmpeg, but haven't found any better options. [1] https://forum.shotcut.org/t/slideshow-generator/19162

ffmpeg has an entire page in their wiki devoted to slideshows: https://trac.ffmpeg.org/wiki/Slideshow

Where I found that fell down was wanting to do things like slow zooms and interesting transitions. I'd love something like a Python or bash script to tweak that addressed those.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#18
Here's a bit of feedback, in the event anyone who manages the site reads this comment section:

1) I checked the FAQ and the 2nd and 3rd question in the FAQ were about crashing on Windows. I get the impression that this software is extremely unstable across OSes. This is a really bad foot to start off on.

Can anyone speak to the stability of Shotcut? I see a few comments below mentioning crashes, I just can't tell if we're talking every month or so, or every 5 minutes. If I were to switch video editors, having the program crash on me constantly is obviously a very big problem.

2) I didn't see any obvious language defining why I should switch to Shotcut. I use kdenlive to cut up screen shares and render them to webm; I do occasional light editing work to make tutorials for people. Kdenlive is a little clunky in some ways, but it gets the job done and I was able to figure out the basics after watching a quick tutorial on YouTube.

So...what does Shotcut offer that kdenlive doesn't? How could this task be made easier? Both software options can be used for commercial use, so what's the benefit of Shotcut over kdenlive? If Shotcut renders quicker, or supports more file formats, or makes it somehow easier to edit videos, I can see the appeal but there doesn't appear to be any introductory literature on their landing page or FAQ hammering these points home. Granted, I could probably devote the time to figuring this out myself, but it just seems like a lot of effort to learn something that should have been covered on the site.

One of those comparison breakdowns of side-by-side +/- images would have been a good starting point. Maybe it's buried somewhere else on the site, but if it is, it should be moved up to the front of the site, preferably on the main page.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#19
post #14

Anyone use this? Opinions?

For me, Shotcut, Openshot, Flowblade, Olive and Pitivi have been crashing to often to be worth using. Openshot used to be less flaky when I used it a few years ago when it was in GTK but the Qt version has not been stable to me. Kdenlive is amazing though, especially the timegraphs for applying effects, and the clip proxying which makes it amazingly smooth for large projects on old laptops. I don't think any of the o…

I had a really bad experience last time I tried to use Kdenlive.

Even on a pretty powerful system, having a project timeline longer than an hour made the entire interface run at ~5fps for me when adjusting cuts. After that, I started using DaVinci Resolve, which definitely still has problems, but runs like nothing else I've seen.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#20

Shotcut has this one cool feature [1] - drop a bunch of pictures into it and it'll create an animated slide show automatically. I've looked for ways to automate that via something like ffmpeg, but haven't found any better options. [1] https://forum.shotcut.org/t/slideshow-generator/19162

Nice! I think iMovie does this, but I usually use https://www.photofilmstrip.org/en
Post reply on HN