Live data from Hacker News

Rate my startup - deegr

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 51 posts

Re: Rate my startup - deegr

#11
A few quick observations:

At one point, the text at the top started saying "Rate NaN movies".

You seem to start off with extremely popular movies. Those movies seem unlikely to generate a range of ratings. You might consider starting off with movies that a large number of people have rated but which polarize people, which would help differentiate people sooner and improve the quality of the circles.

At one point the "I didn't see this movie" links became french: "Je n'ai pas vu ce film".

In one category, I hit "I didn't see this movie", and later the same movie showed up in another category.

I found it slightly odd that the rating scale goes from 0.5 to 5 stars, rather than 0 to 5 stars.

I rated all the films deegr showed in the first batch, and they all disappeared, but now I don't see an obvious next step. The rotating deegr explanation banners at the top mention something about "refine your search after rating a few movies", and shows an icon for that, but I don't see that icon anywhere in the interface. I finally found that clicking on the "Deegr Circle" dropdown, then "Deegr Circle" under that, led me to something useful.

Once I get to the mode showing a circle of other people, I don't see any options for "I haven't seen this film" anymore.

Once you start recommending a circle of people, and recommending other films liked in that circle, that encourages rating those films too, which seems unlikely to change the circle.

I'd love to see an explanation of the name. Best guess: modified form of "dig"?

Re: Rate my startup - deegr

#13
post #10

This is great, but in spending about 10 minutes on it I only see movies I've already seen - almost every film I came across in those 10 minutes is not new to me and I lost interest. With 100 years of film history to watch, thousands of indie films, foreign films - I want to know what is highly recommended of something more obscure that is worth my time to find. I guess this is just a start for you, it works well othe…

Thanks marquis; I've just edited the main message to say that we're already working on a feature that will enable you to remove mainstream movies in a single click. So please stay tuned, it should be up within a couple of weeks at most :)

Re: Rate my startup - deegr

#14

Why can I rate movies without logging in, but not add movies to the mute list without logging in?

Hey Josh. We prefer to have registered users than visitors, so that you too can be matched and in order to grow the userbase. That's why we've put some features only to be used after registration. On top of that, these feats are useless as a visitor; the muting will be forgotten when you come back after 48hrs.

It takes literally no more than 10 seconds to create an account, you should give it a go ;)

Re: Rate my startup - deegr

#15
post #8

After a few rates I saw "Rate NaN movies". Not good. Then it wasn't clear that I had to click on "deegr circle" to find others that matched me. Finally, I don't think that half stars add any value. Keep it simple.

I found half-stars rather useful; they made it more natural to quickly give an appropriate rating. I frequently find that half-stars make me less inclined to over-rate something; 4.5 contains mostly stuff I would otherwise have rated 5, and 3.5 contains mostly stuff I would rated 4, as well as a few things I would have reluctantly rated 3.

Re: Rate my startup - deegr

#16
post #9

I like it! I actually found a new movie that related to the ratings I supplied, nor have I seen it before, good stuff. Here are some thoughts: 1. I've feed Netflix a lot of my data over the years. A link from each movie to a Netflix result would show how Netflix rates it related to me. Maybe you don't want to push people to Netflix, but it's useful information to me. 2. I don't really care about the "people" I care a…

Thanks coffee, glad you like it.

1. Oh yes we want to push Netflix! We're just a small french project and Netflix has not invaded us as of this date; and is unlikely to do so for sometime, actually. I know what you're talking about and we'll see how/if we can implement it.

2. Well that's a bummer, deegr's all about finding others like you ^^ If we only recommended movies without telling you why you should like them, we'd ressemble every other engine out there! Don't you like knowing you have taste-mates out there?

Re: Rate my startup - deegr

#17
My first impression: what problem does this solve? Why do I want to connect with people with similar movie interests?

After I started rating movies that I've seen, I could see the value in the recommendation engine aspect...

I'm not a fan of the name either... it's not memorable.

Also, it seems that French text shows up every now and then.

Good start, keep iterating.

Re: Rate my startup - deegr

#18
The three icons below films in the "so-and-so also rated" section, which look like a plus, a TV, and a speech bubble, don't immediately suggest obvious functions to me. You might consider either adding floating help for those icons, or making them more obvious.
Post reply on HN